Top TEN Hardest Premier League Footballers Of All Time
The English Premiership is renowned for being one of the hardest and most keenly contested leagues in the world. Crunching tackles are common place and many a player would never dream of jumping out of a tackle. But the Premiership’s hardest players have some way to go to compete with one female footballer who is taking competitiveness to a whole new level. 20 year old American defender Elizabeth Lambert certainly gets stuck in when she plays as this video shows:
Lambert has been banned by her college team for her antics in that match, where she was kicking, punching and yanking opponents to the ground by their hair. Lambert is quoted in the Daily Mail as saying “I let my emotions get the best of me in a heated situation,” you can say that again. Whilst hard men in the Premier League may not go as far as the American defender during a game, some genuine tough players have played in England in the past. Here is a look at the top ten hardest players to ever play in the Premiership:
10: Jaap Stam – The 6 ft 3 in Manchester United and Netherlands central defender was certainly a formidable opponent to come up against. Stam was a straight character who was said to have a serious approach to football, and he went into every tackle as if it were his last. Centre forwards rarely had the better of battles with the Dutchman as his build and physique was up there with anyone. In his PSV days it is rumoured that a fight on the field immediately ended as soon as Stam came towards the confrontation. He definitely wasn’t a man to be messed with.
9: Colin Hendry – An old fashioned central defender, Hendry was as hard as granite and had an uncompromising approach to the art of defending. His tough nature meant that if the ball was in the air he would go and head it and nothing would get in his way. He once described a swinging elbow as shrugging off another player and was banned for six international matches as a result. The defender led Blackburn to the FA Premier League title back in 1995 and had courage in abundance, which he will need plenty of when he stars in I’m a Celebrity Get Me Out of Here later this year.
8: Neil Ruddock – ‘Razor’ Ruddock was involved in plenty of bust ups during his football career, most famously clashing with Frenchmen Eric Cantona and Patrick Vieira. He seemed to enjoy dishing punishment out to his opponents and brought plenty of steel to the Liverpool defence for a number of years. His reputation as a hard man goes before him and to this day when he still appears in testimonials and charity matches he doesn’t exactly back out of tackles, as celebrity Tim Lovejoy will testify after geting his comeuppance after taking the mickey out of him.
7: Julian Dicks – The West Ham defender would have been more suited to playing football before his time, as he was a traditional hard man. The tough tackler had the nickname ‘The Terminator’ and many of his challenges were enough to make your eyes water. The shaven-headed defender sure had the look of a hard man and his no nonsense approach endeared him to the Hammers’ fans. It seems since retiring he hasn’t lost any of his aggression either, as Dicks has admitted that he has smashed his golf clubs in anger after losing his rag after a fluffed shot.
6: Marco Materazzi – The Italian defender is known as ‘The Matrix’ due to his unpredictable personality and wasn’t adverse to a crunching tackle every now and again. Materazzi seemed to have a switch that when he got angry he took it out on his opponents and illustrated that during his time in the Premiership with Everton. He knew how to wind up opponents as well as the infamous incident with French legend Zidane proves. He was head butted by Zidane after allegedly insulting the Frenchman’s family and got a taste of what he himself dished out during his career.
Pages: 1 2


Uuuuhhh… Patrick Vieira IS back in England, only with Man City.
Sorry Bud, But Keane and Pearce would not come near big Dunc if we are on about Hard Men…nowhere near!
What a load of rubbish. These are the hardest players in the eyes of the media.
On the pitch then you can’t look past Kevin Ball. Vinnie Jones said that he tried to hurt Ball but Bally got back up and clattered Vinny Jones about 5 minutes later, hurting Jones. He said he’s the hardest player he’s played against.
As for Vieira, I saw him go in for a 50-50 with Gavin McCann at the SoL years ago, the ball burst, McCann walked off, and Vieira was carried off.
In my opinion, Kevin Ball, Alan Shearer, Kevin Davies, Patrice Evra (who was a cage fighter in France) and Emerson Thome should be on the list.
Hard, you call these blokes hard, they are all pussies compared to Chopper Harris and Norman hunter.
What a totally useless list. What No Chopper Harris, Norman “bites yer legs” Hunter, Dave McKay, Billy Bremner all of these guys would have eaten your list alive
Jarra: PAtrice Evra was never a cage fighter…lol…involved in proffessional football since he was 11!
Nigel de Jong
Anyway, it’s a useless article. It would depend if you are talking, people who have played football who you wouldn’t mess with, or just hard – fair players. The list given, is generally the ‘wouldn’t mess with’ option I would say.
David Batty?
What, no Tommy Smith, Nobby Stiles, or Norman Hunter? How long have you watched football for?
Lorik Cana ?
No Arsene Wenger?, he’s had far more red cards than anyone in the entire history of PL football, but you’ll not see any one of them,Mr Hypocrite himself. You’re not allowed to be hard anymore, which leaves only cynical and calculated cowards to do the business on the field, and equally cowardly managers to defend their players and the instructions given to them. If you want to prevent this cynical type of football, start fining the managers, you’ll see it drop overnight, same applies to dissent!
AKASH. are you some kind of backward window licker???? numky
Keane used to regularly hide from Duncan Ferguson in Everton v Utd games and Pierce was just a pussy compared to him . One thing about Big Dunc was he was never sly or undehand , if someone upset him he just let them know in his own way in full view of everyone . Ask Ruddock …..
and by the way it depends what you class as a hard player, Stuart Pearce was a hard player, Tony Adams was a hard player…..neither were thugs unlike most mentioned in so called “hard men lists”
mick harford was the hardest in the craZy gang!!!!! Dunc wud pummel keane!!!! n Cantona wud av smashed keane too!!!
How can Vinnie Jones be there? Soft as. Also how can Roy Keane be there when he absolutely bottled it against Shearer, oh, and Ferguson? Surely the fact Duncan Ferguson fractured someone’s skull entitles him to be higher up the list than someone who stared before waiting for a ref to get between him and Shearer?
Roy Keane?? wasnt that hard when Shearer squared up to him and laughed in his face, twice !
Loved this list, compiled by a 10 year old who knows nothing football.
I supppose he’s never heard of Gerry Byrne? Gerry was as hard as they come and played for most of the 1965 Cup Final, (plus extra time), with a broken collar bone. He still got stuck in despite the pain. Contrast that with modern players who writhe around if their nail varnish gets smudged.
Graham Roberts? – not a man to mess with
Duncan Ferguson by a mile,
Roy Keane 2nd and John Fashanu 3rd – This is a Premier League List so The Old Players are Not Eligible.
Gerry Byrne, Tommy Smith, Nobby Stiles, etc … hard, absolutely – Premiership … I don’t think so.
Read the title
If you want hard. Bobby Smith.
Look at his record for Spurs & England. These nancy boys today would run away and hide.
I am a Spurs fan and a couple of names come to mind such as Graham Roberts, Paul Millar, Pat Van den Hauwe and Dave Mackay come to mind,
It’s a pity that the don’t differentiate between “hard” and “dirty”. Prior to the premiership, as has already been mentioned, there were players like Dave Mackay and Graham Roberts, both of whom were hard, but they were never dirty.
Praising someone because they were prepared to put the boot or an elbow in, is really praising someone for cheating. I would imagine that their fans would be the first to scream when thsy have a penalty awarded against them after a referee has ben conned with a blatant dive.
No Grahame Souness. Anyone who knows English football would put souey up there.
Viera? WTF is he doing in there? Hard? No chance. He was a pussy.
How can Stuart Pearce be aheaed of Big Dunc? Ferguson is still the only player in British footballing history to go to jail for actions on the field.
And as for the Viera commentary… who wrote this article? He plays for City now and has in no way been linked with Arsenal.
Oh, and Marco Materazzi? I’m an Evertonian so spent a lot of time watching him. He was no different from any Italian. He hit the floor as soon as a feather hit him. The 6th hardest man in Premier League history? Give me a break.
So many pointless comments here made by people who didn’t read the title of the Article. PREMIERSHIP PLAYERS.
The order and even thoses included and not included are all subjective and this is one persons opinion to stimulate debate. The hardest Premiership player I ever saw play was big Duncan Ferguson but being hard is pointless if your not also a skillfull footballer,Duncan was a great player IMO but some of those in the list were more thugs than hard footballers.
Gotta be big dunc by a country mile I’m sure there is a couple of robbers that will back me up with that. I remember watching the blues against Leeds when they were on a downer and had loads of loans playing for them and I’m pretty sure it was junior bayano (not 100% it was him or the spelling) but by the time dunc finished with him he was battered with a few threads of what used to be a shirt, Roy keane 1st I don’t think so.
carlos tevez is as hard as nails. most argentines are
Ye mar on toast lids. Not one of you has peyabs.
Duncan Ferguson would absolutely do every one on that list. Stuart Pearce number 2??????? you must be kidding.
if this list wasnt confined to the premiership days then Tommy Smith would almost certainly be at the top. the hardest footballer to ever live.
Keano is the deseserved victor.Lion of a man.Fearless and ferocious.Never forget how hard as nails he was when he came back from his injury. Never seen someone more angry on a football pitch.