Top TEN players ‘tipped for the top’ who failed to live up to the hype

Date: 25th August 2010 at 7:38 pm
Written by Jack Howlett

Before the start of the new campaign I wrote a piece about the young Premier League starlets to watch out for. Amongst these much heralded and discussed youngsters were the likes of Marc Albrighton, Jack Wilshere, Jack Rodwell and Phil Jones. Whilst these players undoubtedly have promising futures, football is full of talented players tipped by managers, team-mates and fans who did not make the grade. Below are ten of those who were lavished with praise but failed to match expectations.

Lee Hendrie

Aged 33, the former Aston Villa player is currently without a club following his departure from Derby County. The midfielder who along with Gareth Barry was once the talk of Villa Park was tipped to be a future England star. He made one substitute appearance for the national team and was signed by Sheffield United in 2007. He was subsequently farmed out to Leicester City and Blackpool. Henrie played the latter half of last season at Brighton and Hove Albion.

Francis Jeffers

With his ‘fox in the box’ label still intact, Jeffers was signed by Arsene Wenger from Everton for £8 million on 2001. He failed spectacularly at Highbury, leaving in 2004 after which his playing destinations seemed to have been planned with all the precision of a drunk throwing darts at a map. The 29-year old striker recently had a prolonged period at Hillsborough but was ostracized after head-butting Port Vale player, Tommy Fraser in the League Cup last year. He trained with Blackpool this summer but has not yet been offered a contract by Ian Holloway.

Neil Mellor

He progressed rapidly through the youth and reserve teams at Liverpool before joining West Ham on loan which only brought a meagre goal return. The strong, burly striker returned to Anfield to score the winner against Arsenal in 2004 and netted against Olympiakos in the Champions League. Injuries and inconsistent form saw him move to Preston North End in 2006 but has since joined up with former manager, Alan Irvine at Sheffield Wednesday.

Michael Ricketts

The centre-forward once earned an England cap after coming to prominence after playing a crucial role in Bolton Wanderers’ promotion to the PL. His impressive goal tally continued in the top flight where he scored the winning goal in the Trotters’ 2-1 away victory at Old Trafford. He was signed by Middlesbrough for £3 million in 2003 but in the intervening years has turned out for numerous clubs across the leagues. He is a free agent after being released by Tranmere Rovers this summer.

Luke Chadwick

Cambridge born Chadwick came through the youth system at Old Trafford but could not cement a regular place in the Manchester United line-up. The midfielder who spent long periods on loan was eventually bought by West Ham in 2004. Further loan spells and transfers continued for Chadwick who can now be found plying his trade at MK Dons.

Continued on Page TWO

Pages: 1 2

Rate this article

6 votes Vote!!
 

Related Articles

10 Comments

  • Jacob says:
    Date: August 25th, 2010 at 8:56 pm

    The top ten flops all came from the last 15 years? Wow, what are the chances? Or perhaps you only started watching football in the mid-1990s. Yeah, that sounds more likely.

    The Manchester United youngsters in your list (Chadwick, Eckersley, Cooke and Thornley) were never “hyped” at all. They were decent players who just weren’t good enough for United – there’s no shame in that.

    I don’t remember any hype about Balaban or Hendrie either but the rest of your list is okay for what it is.

    Reply

    says: The top ten flops all came from the last 15 years? Wow, what are the chances? Or perhaps you only started watching football in the mid-1990s. Yeah, that sounds more likely. The Manchester United youngsters in your list (Chadwick, Eckersley, Cooke and Thornley) were never "hyped" at all. They were decent players who just weren't good enough for United - there's no shame in that. I don't remember any hype about Balaban or Hendrie either but the rest of your list is okay for what it is.
    Jacob
  • Akash,33 says:
    Date: August 25th, 2010 at 9:36 pm

    ………..
    ………..
    LETS PLAY 4-3-3 Attacking Game…..

    Reina
    Johnson-Carragher-Skrtel/Agger-Aurelio
    Gerrard-Mascherano-Cole
    Kuyt-Torres-Babel/Jovanovic

    Play…
    Attack-Attack-Attack and Attack..
    Kill Every Team That We’re Meet.!

    Reply

    says: ……….. ……….. LETS PLAY 4-3-3 Attacking Game….. Reina Johnson-Carragher-Skrtel/Agger-Aurelio Gerrard-Mascherano-Cole Kuyt-Torres-Babel/Jovanovic Play… Attack-Attack-Attack and Attack.. Kill Every Team That We're Meet.!
    Akash,33
  • brad says:
    Date: August 25th, 2010 at 9:43 pm

    http://www.pornhub.com

    you two need to get laid, to much testosterone.

    Reply

    says: www.pornhub.com you two need to get laid, to much testosterone.
    brad
  • brad says:
    Date: August 25th, 2010 at 9:44 pm

    and as for you Akash,33
    i wanna smoke what your smoking

    Reply

    says: and as for you Akash,33 i wanna smoke what your smoking
    brad
  • justin mottershead says:
    Date: August 26th, 2010 at 12:31 am

    Ben Thornley does not deserve to be on this list because he didn’t ‘fail’ at anything. A near career-ending injury when he was still in his teens, in a reserve game against Blackburn, by Nicky Marker ended any chance he had of performing at the top level.
    It was only through sheer determination and hard graft that Thornley was able to carve out a professional career at all.

    Reply

    says: Ben Thornley does not deserve to be on this list because he didn't 'fail' at anything. A near career-ending injury when he was still in his teens, in a reserve game against Blackburn, by Nicky Marker ended any chance he had of performing at the top level. It was only through sheer determination and hard graft that Thornley was able to carve out a professional career at all.
    justin mottershead
  • Freddie says:
    Date: August 26th, 2010 at 9:14 am

    Did Chadwick’s demise coincide with the mickey being ripped out of him on They Think It’s All Over?

    Reply

    says: Did Chadwick's demise coincide with the mickey being ripped out of him on They Think It's All Over?
    Freddie
  • gash asne says:
    Date: August 26th, 2010 at 11:24 am

    see how frgie is good in nurturing great talents … so do those at villa park

    Reply

    says: see how frgie is good in nurturing great talents ... so do those at villa park
    gash asne
  • Top Gooner says:
    Date: August 26th, 2010 at 4:24 pm

    Spot on Gash Asne. Apart from Gary Pallister, Paul Ince, Mark Robins, Ryan Giggs, Andrei Kanchelskis, Lee Sharpe, Roy Keane, David Beckham, Gary Neville, Nicky Butt, Phil Neville, Paul Scholes, Wes Brown, John O’Shea, Cristiano Ronaldo, Darren Fletcher, Wayne Rooney, Nani, Anderson, Jonny Evans, Rafael, Darron Gibson and a few others, I can’t think of any young talents nurtured by Fergie at United. He’s no Arsene Wenger that’s for sure!

    Reply

    says: Spot on Gash Asne. Apart from Gary Pallister, Paul Ince, Mark Robins, Ryan Giggs, Andrei Kanchelskis, Lee Sharpe, Roy Keane, David Beckham, Gary Neville, Nicky Butt, Phil Neville, Paul Scholes, Wes Brown, John O'Shea, Cristiano Ronaldo, Darren Fletcher, Wayne Rooney, Nani, Anderson, Jonny Evans, Rafael, Darron Gibson and a few others, I can't think of any young talents nurtured by Fergie at United. He's no Arsene Wenger that's for sure!
    Top Gooner
  • Chris says:
    Date: August 27th, 2010 at 12:35 pm

    Lee Hendrie, really?

    He had 9/10 quality years at Villa Park scoring some great goals

    Reply

    says: Lee Hendrie, really? He had 9/10 quality years at Villa Park scoring some great goals
    Chris
  • gash asne says:
    Date: February 1st, 2011 at 5:57 am

    the difference is that was of three squads may be for over 2 decades … may be couple of years more except the fergi babies .. which make the whole of your list …. check out the whole arsenal squad .. you fake gooner …. for the past 14 years … and you will know that … nurturing is not about … buying for 20 some thing million … did you have any idea for how much anderson … nani .. christiano ronaldo … rooney cost united … hahaha very funny…

    Reply

    says: the difference is that was of three squads may be for over 2 decades ... may be couple of years more except the fergi babies .. which make the whole of your list .... check out the whole arsenal squad .. you fake gooner .... for the past 14 years ... and you will know that ... nurturing is not about ... buying for 20 some thing million ... did you have any idea for how much anderson ... nani .. christiano ronaldo ... rooney cost united ... hahaha very funny...
    gash asne

Leave a Comment



Your Comment:

Subscribe to our VIP mailing list

Enter Security Code:

If you want your picture to display next to your comments head on over to gravatar.com to get your free 'globally recognised avatar'. It will work on many other sites and forums too and all you need to sign up is an email address!