FanCasts

Sit back, relax and listen to our FREE Football Podcasts. Subscribe 4 FREE to get your teams show each week.

Blogs

Intelligent, articulate, opinion. Read, rate and comment!

Banter

Create your own discussion and debate - Sign up and get involved!

Football FanCast columnist Frank Winter looks at Spurs' desire to play hardball with regards to Berbatov and wonders at what point Sir Alex says enough is enough and looks elsewhere.

Dimitar Berbatov is undoubtedly one of the best strikers in Europe at the moment and his arrival at Old Trafford would be welcomed, but at what price? According to reports in the Guardian this morning, Spurs have decided to play hardball and looking to United to up the ante, but I feel we should hold firm and if they don't succumb to our ‘take it or leave it' standpoint, then we should look elsewhere.

You don't have to be brain of Britain to work out that Sir Alex needs to bring in another striker into the club. We were heavily reliant on Cristiano Ronaldo to provide the goals last season and for all of Rooney and Tevez's contributions last season, you would hardly call either prolific.

We have been linked with plenty of strikers in the past few weeks but the two names that are most prominent in most supporters wish lists are Berbatov and my own personal choice Klass Jan Huntelaar. Don't get me wrong I am a huge fan of the Bulgarian and feel he will do a fantastic job at United, but for me Huntelaar is more prolific and would provide that predatory instinct in front of goal that we so desperately lack.

Klass Jan Huntelaar is currently the most prolific striker in Europe and his goalscoring record at Ajax is comparable to what Ruud van Nistelrooy's was when he was at PSV. He shares a lot of the same characteristics that Ruud possesses in front of goal, although offer's slightly more in and around the box; something our former Dutchman failed to contribute and in truth was the reason that Sir Alex felt the need to move him on. He also works out at around £10m cheaper than the reported fee Spurs are after and unlike the North Londoners, Ajax are seemingly prepared to do business.

So what is the best deal for Manchester United and is Berbatov really a better option than Huntelaar? With Spurs prepared to play hardball, like they did with Carrick, I just wonder at what point does Sir Alex Ferguson declare enough is enough and look elsehwere?

Poll:

  • Average: 5 (1 vote)
Georgie
Picture of Georgie
He aint worth £25m
He aint worth £25m especially when we can can get Huntelaar of Falcao for around £15m. Berbatov is no different to what we have got with Rooney, what we need is a goalscorer, not another provider.

JEFF
Picture of JEFF
WE SHOULDNT BOW DOWN TO
WE SHOULDNT BOW DOWN TO THEIR VALUATION BECAUSE THE PLAYER WILL KICK UP A STINK AND THEY WILL HAVE TO BACK DOWN - WE JUST NEED TO SIT TIGHT.

Sidders
Picture of Sidders
More to the point when do
More to the point when do Tottenham decide that enough is enough?

Paul Jones
Picture of Paul Jones
Huntelaar is the better
Huntelaar is the better player, wants to join us so it is a no brainer for me. Berbatov is a good player but no different a forward to rooney or tevez.

George 1 I
Picture of George 1 I
The very cheek of them.We
The very cheek of them.We should be saying enough is enough.Poor story Frank.

COME ON YOU SPURS
Picture of COME ON YOU SPURS
We shouldnt bow down, just
We shouldnt bow down, just sit tight, i assume your ok with the way Ronaldo is treating the club that established him then?

Matt
Picture of Matt
If you want our player then
If you want our player then you have to pay for him, our club is not a breeding ground so that you can come and lift our best players on the cheap when you feel like it. We took the gamble on bringing Berbatov to the PL for £11m, if you want him that bad then pay the asking price, not haggle for a fee. If not do one!!!

Bryan
Picture of Bryan
The problem is that Spurs
The problem is that Spurs aren't in financial difficulty so aren't crying out for the money. Berbatov can kick up a stink all he likes but he's still contracted to Tottenham so they hold all the aces. We're best of going for Huntelaar. Much better value for money and a better goalscorer.

kev
Picture of kev
WE SHOULDNT BOW DOWN TO
WE SHOULDNT BOW DOWN TO THEIR VALUATION BECAUSE THE PLAYER WILL KICK UP A STINK AND THEY WILL HAVE TO BACK DOWN - WE JUST NEED TO SIT TIGHT.for berbatov and they(spurs) substitute ronaldo and they( real Madrid)

andy
Picture of andy
You're not trying to buy a
You're not trying to buy a house. There is no forward chain here. Fergie and the media seems to think that being patient means the price will go down but we don't need the money so if we want £30 million and you don't pay then he stays for another year. Personally I would love Fergie to say enough is enough then we wouldn't have to put up with all the scurrilous rumours in the tabloid press.