FanCasts

Sit back, relax and listen to our FREE Football Podcasts. Subscribe 4 FREE to get your teams show each week.

Blogs

Intelligent, articulate, opinion. Read, rate and comment!

Banter

Create your own discussion and debate - Sign up and get involved!

Football FanCast columnist and Newcastle Utd man Chris Mackin looks back at the easy day at the office on Sunday and wonders whatever happened to great revolution that was supposedly happening down the road.

There was a bloke by me up near the top of the Milburn stand on Sunday who was clearly a Sunderland fan. Edgy and silent throughout, and conspicuously subdued when Owen scored his first, he eventually left when Newcastle got their penalty never to be seen again. Timid and meek, his presence was ill advised and sensibly re-assessed and aborted at half time. He will take little solace in his role yesterday as a walking literacy device, particularly as his otherwise note perfect allegorical performance, his on the money metaphorical channelling of his team's dismal showing, did not extend to the "re-assessed and aborted at half time" bit.

Always fond of- and tremendously skilled at- making themselves look foolish, Sunderland fans have spent the duration of Newcastle's recent run of form dismissing the defeated teams- Fulham, Reading and Spurs- as hapless also-rans; the Portsmouth team we drew with apparently distracted and playing to avoid injury. How typical of Newcastle supporters they all said, putting words into our mouths and too distracted by laughing at their own jokes to notice than at no point had any Newcastle supporter actually got over excited or claimed that we are going to win the league next season.

Shoddy nobodies there to be beaten, not at all a testament to the good work Kevin has been getting on with, that was their position. It was a argument carefully crafted to ignore lots of crucial factors- Keegan's tactics tinkering, Reading's spirited performance at St. James and the fact that outside of the top four the Premiership is one giant splodge of indistinguishable mush anyway - but it wasn't until Sunday that we realized how tremendously inappropriate and hypocritical their dismissal of ‘Spurs and Reading had been. You could argue on one hand that if anybody was well placed to judge hopeless Premiership teams it would be Sunderland supporters, on the other you wonder how a set of fans watching such a shocking team feel well placed to comment on other's failings, it goes way beyond throwing stones in glass houses, they were placing mining devices under the foundations and going after the windows with hammers, they may as well have been taunting Southampton supporters about their red and white shirts.

So the great revolution they've been boring everybody about was all a giant fraud after all. The worst Sunderland team for many a year came with a cowardly game plan, a manager with as much tactical acumen and ability to motivate as a damp and underfed kitten and in Paul McShane a footballer so bad he makes Ali Dai with a hangover look like Edison Arantes do Nascimento.

Seeing a bad Sunderland side at St. James' is hardly a novelty, but there was a genuine sense of disbelief about the haplessness of this one, our players seemed as shocked as us, they spent the entire second half misplacing passes and getting forward sluggishly, seemingly double checking the fliers to confirm they got the right date. "Oh", everybody said at the final whistle, "maybe they'll give us a game next time".

Ask Sunderland fans to name their best players and they'd probably say Jones- lively and handy in the air, talented but limited and not quite the Hristro Stoichkov they had disingenuously led us to believe he was; or Reid, who fluffed as many of his neat little passes on Sunday as he completed and who's only function appeared to be acting as a handy rejoinder to the Sunderland supporter's taunts about Viduka's weight. They rate Evans too, but their problem on Sunday in defence on Sunday wasn't Evans' absence, it was McShane's presence, and as Evans is actually a Manchester United player who Alex Ferguson presumably rates less than Wes Brown and Roy Keane signed McShane they may want to be choosy about how vocal they are about the relative strengths and failings of the two. The rest of them are classless plodders, heavy footed and anonymous with as much wit and imagination on the ball as a warm up comedian making jokes about women drivers.

Their support on Sunday too, not so much responding to theirs team performance as mirroring it directly, was inexplicably silent throughout. "Don't you always win 2-1?", the Newcastle fans chanted at one point and though it was a chant that betrayed the amount of alcohol we'd all consumed and our devilishly ironic nature there was also a genuine imploration to it; we fancied a bit of a boogie and a sing song with them and they didn't want to know, hanging out in the corner by the bar and avoiding eye contact all night. Impolite, frankly.

Before the match Niall Quinn, with astonishing lack of accuracy, looked back on the ‘99 derby he played and scored in as a night when "top of the table Newcastle were defeated by little Sunderland" and, thus affronted, responded by sacking their manager. It's a bizarre way to reminisce on a game wherein second bottom of the league Newcastle were beaten by mid-table Sunderland, but is helpful as a tuition on how Sunderland view the game of football; sneakily twisting every fact to fit in with their skewered perception of a cruel world that exists solely to lay grief on their doorstep, always being downtrodden and ridiculed or outright ignored by The Man operating on the behest of Big Nasty Newcastle United.

This insane jealous streak and inferiority complex makes them unpleasant enough, adding delusions of grandeur into the mix made them simply unbearable. So, relief then, that their team made a mockery of their claims of skill, grit and potential; not a great derby match but more than satisfying, a gleeful bursting of balloons and wounding of egos, I only hope they have enough bottle in them to see off Bolton and Birmingham in the next few weeks to give us the opportunity to re-schedule for next year.

Poll:

  • Average: 3 (4 votes)
DJ
Picture of DJ
Absolutely class piece of
Absolutely class piece of writing, every detail you have covered has hit the nails on the head!! Class!!! SMB

Super Mag
Picture of Super Mag
A fantatsic read and as your
A fantatsic read and as your man said spot on in every respect. We didnt have to get out of first gear all day to win this game. We have our worst season of all time and we are still above them.

syd
Picture of syd
Easy a derby win than we
Easy a derby win than we have had in many a year.

Eric Vincent
Picture of Eric Vincent
I agree with every word.
I agree with every word. Superb piece of writing. SMB.

safctony
Picture of safctony
firstly, how do you come to
firstly, how do you come to the conclusion that SAF rates wes brown more than jonny evans?? brown is a right back, evans is a centre back so you cant compare the two. secondly, the only reason mcshane was playing is because both evans and bardsley were injured. This isn't an excuse as to why we were so utterly shocking, but playing a game against your 3 up top would be hard enough with our first choice back 4, never mind with half of that missing. the only stand that was singing throughout the game was the stand to the left of us, and even that stand was full of young kids and charvas. The Gallowgate - the most mighty and impressive stand in world football as you lot would like people to believe - was very quiet, and the only time I saw them on their feet apart from the two goals was when they were streaming out of the exits on 85 minutes. You even had to print words to 'your anthem' in the programme. Yes we were shocking, yes keanos tactics and substitutions left a lot to be desired, but the fact is your fantastic unbeaten run has only seen you beat teams in the bottom half of the table, and draw against a distracted pompey side who seem to enjoy drawing 0-0 at home, but never-the-less a good result. It will be interesting to evaluate you lot again after the next 3 games against teams in the top half of the table. Roll on next season p.s. - your song about keano and his dog, its a bitch, so he cant do that!!

awful game
Picture of awful game
Bloody hell, I'm a mackem
Bloody hell, I'm a mackem and even I have to agree with half of that. One of the worst performances, and in McShane one of the worst individual performances I have ever seen in a derby. Still, we have room for improvement, NUFC only have room to self-destruct as they always seem to manage.

REDJ
Picture of REDJ
You nufc fans are jokers and
You nufc fans are jokers and this is why What are Newcastle United's aspirations for next season?: Top 10 Top 8 Uefa Cup CL other...... behave who do think your going to sign messi,henry,kaka, you won`t be anywhere near the top 4 and you talk about keegans tactics did`nt no he had any apart from attack the games changed since you fell apart in the league and of all the world class strikers out the no of them are geordies like shearer. what a waste of a great player, and how long do you think it will take owen to decide on his future if say a club like man city come in for him. the best you jokers can hope for is doing the master league on pro 08 then you might have a chance of signing world class players and winning something.

Johnythehorse
Picture of Johnythehorse
The arrogance
The arrogance continues.Newcastle were poor in the second half because they were stunned by how poor Sunderland were!!!!The reality is that before the game there were 3 points between the teams and that Sunderland were awfull on the day.The reasons include the loss of Evans and Bardsley,the fact that the replacements had 1 game between them in the previous few months and the managers team selection and set up/tactics which proved to be wrong.Some of the Newcastle passing in the second half was very poor.Take away Owen Martins Butt and the right back and you are not very good either.Re the obvious Sunderland fan in the Milburn stand,did you spend the first half watching him or the match.Please remember you are Newcastle and not Man Utd and just remind us all of the trophies you have.While you are on can you list the managers before Keegans tenure for all your skunk charver chums.

George Reilly
Picture of George Reilly
As a Sunderland fan can I
As a Sunderland fan can I just agree we are insanely jealous of a team that never wins ANYTHING. PS The most famous game in your entire history is a defeat off HEREFORD !

observer
Picture of observer
well written, if not a bit
well written, if not a bit too subjective.In all fairness you make the point of Keegan being allowed time to tinker so surely you should at least give Keane time to actually learn his trade and even worse, at the highest level where every mistake is punished.he has made mistakes but it will be a great achievement to keep them in the premiership.As a neutral the thing I did notice was how emphatically Newcastle's fans celebrated winning the game.Usually I would have always thought Sunderland would have seen this game as more of a big derby than Newcastle, who had bigger fish to fry.But at last a dose of reality is sinking in and they realise they aren't up there with the big boys and haven't been since the 1920's.