FanCasts

Sit back, relax and listen to our FREE Football Podcasts. Subscribe 4 FREE to get your teams show each week.

Blogs

Intelligent, articulate, opinion. Read, rate and comment!

Banter

Create your own discussion and debate - Sign up and get involved!

Football FanCast columnist Sam Hollis looks at the crazy turnover of managers in the modern game and feels that its time that the players took more responsibility.

If Andy Ritchie is the nicest manager in the game, why was he sacked on Tuesday? Huddersfield Town are sitting quite comfortably mid-table in League One with no danger of relegation; which suggests his chairman had expected promotion. But if you ask Bournemouth and Luton Town fans - they will tell you it could be a lot worse.

Compare that with Chelsea's defeat last night in Turkey, where afterwards I listened for a good hour while Blues fans slated Avram Grant on a radio phone-in. A man that took over after the start of the season and transformed a hopeless team into genuine title contenders. Arsenal are constantly talked about as the best footballing side in the world - and Chelsea are above them. One defeat in the Champions League later, his own supporters are calling for his head. I can't help but think that the players should stand up and take some responsibility.

Chelsea should have been four or five goals to the good at half time, they created the chances, however Drogba couldn't hit a cows backside with a banjo and it wasn't to be. If the players had taken the chances, we wouldn't be having this discussion. What more is Grant to do? I've always felt that managers get a rough deal. Leeds boss Gary McAllister has been 'rewarded' with a 12 month rolling contract. However you feel if Leeds do no get a play-off spot he will not be at Leeds for 12 months. I know McAllister is genuinely delighted at the deal, but surely a rolling contract does not do wonders for his confidence.

There is so much focus on manager failures that players can seemingly hide behind this while their boss gets the boot. Whether it's Drogba not scoring, Eboue not trying or Huddersfield's inabilty to play football at home.

I have even heard mumbles of discontent at Luton Town, questioning Mick Harford's credentials at manager. Who, as far as I'm concerned, is the only hope left for us Hatters as every week we witness yet more overpaid, under performing players leave the club. Like Avram Grant, he has took over a squad he did not build - it is only fair they are given the same time and respect as their predecessors. Player who do not perform for them can be booted, and subsequently that enables them to bring in hungry players who play for them with their heart on their sleeve. Andy Ritchie was in the process of doing that - before he was sacked.

Avram Grant could be in the peculiar position of losing his job after finishing second in the league and reaching the semi-finals of the Champions League. Who'd be a manager, eh?

  • No votes yet
Terry the Terrier
Picture of Terry the Terrier
Have you been to many
Have you been to many Huddersfield games this season then? Clearly you have, so which of Ritchie's signings would you say are "hungry players playing with their heart on their sleeve"? I'll tell you - one, Robert Page. All his other signings have been pathetic, and the "exciting football" we were promised when he took over has resulted in record low crowds at the Galpharm Stadium this season. Bring in the Mad Dog to inject some passion!

Matthew
Picture of Matthew
Hollis, you are a total
Hollis, you are a total clown - you have ruined your previously credible point by dragging into it a club you clearly have a limited knowledge of. Stick to regurgitating the stuff you read from the pro writers in the daily tabloids. Which i might add rairly contain, unlike your tripe, opinion professing to know the ins and outs of the lower league clubs. You have chanced you arm here, and exposed yourself as a know nothing cretin.

Sam Hollis
Picture of Sam Hollis
Posts: 80
Joined: 2007-10-30
Matthew, i can only assume
Matthew, i can only assume you mean my points on Huddersfield Town. I have in fact seen them play numerous times this season as i currently live in Huddersfield.  I respesct your right to disagree with what i say, afterall - who knows more than the fan! However i stick by my point that managers such as Ritchie should be given more time.

Matthew
Picture of Matthew
You cant have watched them
You cant have watched them that much Sam, or you wouldnt have written that article. They have been pathetic. I also have it on good authority that Ritchie had lost the dressing room. We got down to 6,004 through the gate (we were getting 10,000 in L2), season tickets about to go on sale. From a commercial stand point what would you have done? Its a romantic notion that all managers should be given time, and in many instances I completely agree. Teams with continuty tend to out perform those without. However in using HTFC as example the example for you argument, I think you totally wrong. We 16 players out of contract, a chance for the person in charge to have a clean slate. Ritchie proved that he could not rebuild us a successful team through the standard of his signings. Signings that he himself failed to motivate. Sacking him was the right move. Why should HTFC plod on with the wrong man, yeah he is a naice guy, but he chose his occupation. To stick up for the for Chelsea fans. I think the point you have missed with Grant is that he was not the best man for the job at the start (his record doesnt stand up). Although he has not done badly he has not over performed with the players he has. Something he needed to do if he wanted to win the fans over. If i was a fan of one the richest clubs in Europe. I would want the best man for the job, not the owners mate.

james
Picture of james
wondering why there are
wondering why there are mumblings of discontent about harford? as i'll always maintain, it would be great if he was successful but he's about to relegate his third club in a managerial career that has taken in 4 clubs (the only survival coming because they got shot of him). great player. good number 2. not a very good manager. it's not even possible to argue that admin has taken us down. we're going to go down by more than the 10 points deduction. even the player sales can't be blamed since we only lost 3 first teamers at a stage in the season where we could have realistically avoided relegation. harford wasn't brought in because of his managerial track record. he was brought in by brendan to appease the fans and make him look good. harford raised the morale of the fans but at the same time seemed to destroy the confidence of many of the players (though admittedly after 2 or 3 months some seem to be getting it back - slowly). in the season we've had, the morale of the players is more important than the fans (not often i'd say that's the case). when we start next season with a 15 point deduction, is mick going to get us near the play offs (like leeds have achieved)? or is he going to struggle to get us out of the relegation battle? we don't know yet but i have a worrying feeling about which scenario is more likely. as i've also said before, i don't blame mick for coming back. he loves the club and we love him (yes even me though i don't think he's a good manager). but i'd be far happier if he accepted his limitations and we finally got someone in that has absolutely no connection to the club and so can bring fresh ideas. we have to look outside the club for inspiration since all we have to look up to internally is a history of eating ourselves into oblivion time and again. but i do agree with your assertion that players need to take more responsibility when things go wrong. just a shame you tried to justify it using mick as an example of a wronged manager!

Matthew
Picture of Matthew
Looks like someone else
Looks like someone else agrees that examples you have given are not as cut and dried as you make out. We got over 10,000 at home this weekend, given Donny brought a couple of thousand, but gates are already back up. That would imply to me that there are 2000 Huddersfield Town fans, plus the Luton fan above, that would also disagree with the examples you have given. Even though in my case i generally agree with the point.