FanCasts

Sit back, relax and listen to our FREE Football Podcasts. Subscribe 4 FREE to get your teams show each week.

Blogs

Intelligent, articulate, opinion. Read, rate and comment!

Banter

Create your own discussion and debate - Sign up and get involved!
Tagged: Premiership

Football FanCast columnist Jim McKendry reacts to news that Sunderland owner Niall Quinn is going to back Keane in the summer and wonders, given that Keegan is likely to spend big as well, which set of fans should be the more optimistic about next season's chances.

When Newcastle United entertained Sunderland at St James Park a fortnight ago, it was the first time that both teams had been on a level playing field for some time. Both teams safe from relegation both slumped just below mid table and from a neutral looking in Newcastle could have considered themselves fortunate that they came out victors on the day.

For Sunderland this season must be considered a success as Roy Keane fulfilled the brief of newly promoted clubs and that is to stay in the division. He achieved it with games to spare however you sense that the torch that use to burn inside Keane as a player has started to ignite as a manager. It is clear that after a season of consolidation, the Irishman has set his sights a little higher and wants to see Sunderland challenging in the upper reaches of the Premier League. This of course is what all Mackems want to hear and they would have been buoyed at the news this morning that Niall Quinn has come out this morning and promised there will be a sizeable war chest at his manager's disposal, in order to take Sunderland to the next level.

Newcastle United fans will tell you that this season has been one calamity after another and on paper there certainly shouldn't have been any reason for being down the wrong end of the table. Sam Allardyce didn't quite grasp what this football club is about and how the negative tactics were never going to endear his to the Toon army. I still shake my head at how a manager, who had so much talent available to him, thought that the long ball game was the answer - to think he nearly became England manager. Kevin Keegan has done a fabulous job and in the last few weeks has brought a bit of panache back to the football club and Newcastle United, once the country's great entertainers, look like they could be ready to take off again next season. There is no doubting that Keegan will have the opportunity to bring in players in the summer and I'm sure there are a lot of Toon fans excited in anticipation at who will come in.

So while Middlesbrough's fans are left to worry about their Premier League status, both Newcastle and Sunderland have every reason to be optimistic with the noises that have been coming out of their respective football clubs in recent weeks. What is the target for next season? Who would you like to bring in? More importantly who is going to be the top dog in the Northeast next year?

Poll:

  • No votes yet
Hoxton
Picture of Hoxton
It totally depends how much
It totally depends how much Keano gets in the summer, I reckon he will look to raid manchester united and bring in one or two from there. I would be happy with a top half finish as a starting point and then build gradually, no good putting all our eggs in one basket.

Freeman
Picture of Freeman
If Keegan is given an open
If Keegan is given an open cheque book then there is no reason why we cant be in and around the top 5 next season, key will be keeping Owen at the club. I think the Mackems could actually be comfortable next season, they have a good manager there and given funds he will achieve as well.

Faustino
Picture of Faustino
Which game where you
Which game where you watching...they never had a hope! Both clubs have great managers for the first time in a long time which says it all really. Even with average investment I reckon we'll both do well next year. By which I mean the mackems will stay up and we'll push for Uefa!

Sean
Picture of Sean
We dominated the recent
We dominated the recent derby at St James', which game were you watching? The mackems were awful, dear me. As for next season, Keano has shown how to blow loads of money on a team almost relegated, Keegan blows on Newcastle and gets grief, even though we nearly won the title. Must be small club mentality if 50m is ok to waste on relegation fodder, when the toon were criticised for spending over 100m and not winning the title. I suppose thats what happens at big clubs.

Tom
Picture of Tom
Erm what game were you
Erm what game were you "neutrals" watching. Newcastle controlled the derby with ease and won at a canter. As for them being in a simillar position, well this has been a very bad season for the toon, whilst this has been a very good season for the mackems, We've had to go through some shocking football and then have the post Allardyce hangover whilst keegan taught the players how to play with passion and speed again, none of this possession by the numbers rubbish allardyce tried to persuade us was football. We can attract better players and have an attack minded coach, If we're not between 5th and 8th next season I'd be surprised. We've both got large transfer kittys but so do most other prem teams, Sunderland will leapfrong boro as the no.2 team in the NE thats about it.

Ray a Geordiedoonsooth
Picture of Ray a Geordiedoonsooth
As per the other posts you
As per the other posts you must have watching a different game at the recent derby. Sunderland had 1 chance & we won easily. As for next season I believe we will be a top 6 side and Sunderland will be mid-table with the yorkshire men from Boro struggling but just staying up. It would be good for the area if all 3 sides could be in the top half challenginf for Europe & domestic trophies. With NUFC top dogs of course.

chuck
Picture of chuck
Next couple of seasons at
Next couple of seasons at St.James`, should bring in some defensive help plus some pace in the midfield. There is the base of a decent team, with lots of experience, though getting a bit long in the tooth. However what is interesting is the current stocking of future stars into the youth system, a far sighted policy recently instated. Not saying all the youngsters will become stars, however some undoubtedly will. Looking to challenge for the PL in about two to three years, and some entertaining football.

Mr Reality
Picture of Mr Reality
Sean: An NUFC 'fan' accusing
Sean: An NUFC 'fan' accusing other clubs of blowing money on dross. You couldn't make it up :-) Sunderland almost relegated but Newcastle just failing to win the title ... I don't know which season you were watching but it certainly wasn't this one. Still, mix 'n' match history is a forte.

chris_mackin
Picture of chris_mackin
Posts: 33
Joined: 2008-03-12
In their first premier
In their first premier league season at the Stadium of Light, Sunderland came from 2 down to draw 2-2 with Newcastle and their support celebrated wildly.  It seemed an odd reaction to gaining a point but we all put it down to circumstances and emotion and politely pretended to not notice.  A few years later when they somehow hung on to a 1-1 at St. James's they done the same thing and we realised that they had claimed the draw as theirs; they count it as a moral victory and celebrate accordingly.  This amused Newcastle supporters and provided further evidence of Sunderland's inferiority complex so we let it go, we gave them the draw.  When they tried the same trick in their 15 point season after being beaten 3-2, though, we put our foot down.  They are not allowed to take anything out of defeats against Newcastle, not even their especially heroic ones and paticularly not defeats when they play as inspididly as they did at St. James's in April.  So, well done Faustino, Tom and Sean for stamping out this ridiculous "unfortunate" nonsense before they started doing that irritating rewriting history thing they're pre-disposed to.

Stuart
Picture of Stuart
At last a neutral
At last a neutral commentator! You are spot on that Newcastle were fortunate to win the derby. There is no argument that Sunderland were disappointing in the game, the point is that Newcastle were barely any better. A good goal in the first few minutes was the only thing between the teams and for that reason alone we have to accept Newcastle deserved the points (it was never a penalty). Furthermore they were even luckier to pick up a point at the SOL when they were woeful. Beyond that I never cease to be amazed at the arrogance of many (not all) Newcastle fans. Year after year of premiership money has slipped through there hands, year after year of cash from devoted fans who fill the ground on a regular basis and they are getting excited at the prospect of finishing a point or two above newly promoted Sunderland. It seems to me the more threatened they feel the more patronising they feel they need to be. I expect Sunderland and Newcastle (and Middlesborough as it happens) to be fighting around mid-table next season. Whoever comes out on top may be flirting with 6th or 7th in the league. The team that comes out on top will depend in my opinion not on who spends the most or gets the biggest names it will depend on who can build a team that plays for each other and can manage injuries to their best players and so on. I think Keane and Keegan are both well placed to deliver on this so it should be an exciting season. For what it's worth I think it's great that all of the big north east clubs are in the premiership. It would just be great if the mags could get off their high horse occasionaly and recognise that they have done NOTHING to warrant their feeling of in-built superiority - ever. And for any of you mags who still want to go on about what a great club you are you might like to remember that you have donated 4 of Derby's 11 points to them this season - good effort from a top drawer club.