FanCasts

Sit back, relax and listen to our FREE Football Podcasts. Subscribe 4 FREE to get your teams show each week.

Blogs

Intelligent, articulate, opinion. Read, rate and comment!

Banter

Create your own discussion and debate - Sign up and get involved!
Tagged: Tottenham

On last week's Tottenham FanCast, Harry Hockley and I announced the nominations for our end of season awards. Category's from player of the season, value for money and the "Damien Comolli" award for the worst signing of the year.

Over the next few weeks we will delve into each of the topics for your reading and listening pleasure, starting this week to find out the first recipient of the "Damien Comolli" award

So who is our worst signing of the season? Here are our nominations, feel free to add your own in the comments page we might include them...

 
Younes Kaboul  

The Frenchman has 29 appearances under the belt but has he done enough to convince Spurs fans and Ramos that he has something to offer the club? His comments earlier this week won't have improved his relationship with our Spanish leader but what next for our French bucket of potential?

Kaboul came to WHL with a big reputation and price tag to match, I wanted him to be our long term replacement for King but having watched him on many occasions, he seems devoid of any of the qualities needed to be a top flight centre half. He seems to lose concentration far too easily, his position is poor and although he looks confident on the ball he can't pass the thing to anyone other than the opposing team.

I hope he proves me wrong and the coaching staff get the best out of him, he finds the father figure he needs and becomes a rock at the centre of our defence but I think that is as likely as Robbo stopping a shot from 30 yards!

Kevin-Prince Boateng

Many will say this is a little harsh but I'm just not sure that this guy has what it takes to wear the white shirt. At 21 years of age he has established himself as a player good enough to represent the German under 21s but we haven't seen much of this for Spurs. When Ramos arrived he placed him straight into the starting line up but the Spaniard, who reportedly tried to sign him when he was at Seville, seems to have dropped him from his plans. The arrival of Modric would suggest that not only should Boateng be worried but many of our other under-performing midfielders will be having sleepless nights.

Also, can anyone tell me what hell he is doing and what was that hair do was about earlier on in the season? I know he is the Ghetto kid but it going a bit far. If he learns to pass, shoot and look interested we could have a talent on our hands, maybe Comolli sees something that I don't?

Darren Bent,

Our much talked about £16m signing hasn't really lived up to many Spurs fans expectations.  Eyebrows were certainly raised when Levy smashed the club record to bring in the striker from Charlton, even though we already had the likes of Keane, Berbatov and Defoe at the club. He has failed to settle at the football club and certainly has struggled to reproduce his form he had at the south London club.

Is he really that bad?  He hasn't made the impact that many would expect but I've heard some Spurs fans claiming he's turned a corner and that his return isn't so bad when you look at it?

Well let's do the maths....

Bent
35 appearances (20 as sub) he has returned 8 goals - a ratio of 0.23 goals per game,

Keane
53 appearances (8 as sub) he has returned 23 goals - a ratio of 0.42 goals per game,

Berbatov
51 appearances (4 as sub) he has returned 23 goals - a ratio of 0.45 goals per game

Even the departed Jermain Defoe's ratio for us and Portsmouth this season notches up a ratio of 0.39 so does it mean we got rid of the wrong striker? That's a topic for another day. Can Bent turn the corner, win over the Spurs fans and grab a place in Capello's squad? Is Juande Ramos going to give him more time at WHL to prove his worth?


Will Darren Bent, the Fresh Prince or Kaboul win the much coveted "Damien Comolli" award - Cast your vote below and post and we will announce the winner on the next Tottenham Football FanCast.


 

 

Poll:

  • No votes yet
jams
Picture of jams
I think people have been far
I think people have been far to quick to judge Kaboul. If King had been fit at the begining of the season, then Kaboul wouldn't have half of the appearances that he has. Being a centre back is probably the most under pressure position to play in, and we all know that Dawson, as good as he is, is not the leader of any centre back pairing, hense the drop in his form when he became the senior centre back. Just look at how his form has improved since the arrival of Woodgate. Im not denying that Kaboul has made mistakes; he's made a couple of howlers, but so what. No one is perfect, and when he gets used to the pace of the prem, Spurs will see the best of him. I think next season, assuming King will not be fit, the first choice centre backs should be Woodgate and Daws, with Kaboul and Dervitte as back up. There is no gaurantee that the likes of Dani Jarque or Madlung (quality name) will fair any better in there first season in the prem than what Kaboul did; and he'll always be a legend in my eyes for his six yard screamer against villa to make it 4 all!

fuzzy dunlop
Picture of fuzzy dunlop
I'm a believer of judging
I'm a believer of judging players & managers over time, but if I had to say one it would have to be Bent. He's a Prem striker no doubt and will score goals at many clubs, I dont think he will be ever able to cement a first team place with us and it's hard to expect him to come in here and there and do the business. Ultimately the amount of money he cost is the problem. Kaboul & Boateng both could quite easily be real talents in the long run but neither can be given much praise this season, especially Kaboul for spitting the dummy. It's a pity he didn't come in and instantly achieve but the fact is he kept making mistakes and shouldn't expect to keep playing, but should wait for his chance and then live up to his hype and price tag. All in all I wouldn't be surprised if all 3 leave in the summer so at the end of the day they've all been as bad a seach other in the 1 season we've had to judge. It would be fair to say the dire showings from everyone in the squad all season makes it a bit unfair to slag any of these new boys off. I mean I'm still coming to terms with Zokora's signing and continued selection to criticise anybody else.

Mark
Picture of Mark
A player that cost £16.5
A player that cost £16.5 million should atleast score a goal a game

Heston
Picture of Heston
We should give Kaboul more
We should give Kaboul more time to estabish himself, he was no worse than anyone else in the back four.

Dex
Picture of Dex
Darren Bent has been the
Darren Bent has been the worst signing in years, we pay £16m for bent and sell Defoe for £8m, crazy decision.

N17
Picture of N17
Freddie Prince Boateng has
Freddie Prince Boateng has been a complete wast of time money and effort, he maks Jermain Jenas look like a world beater.

Sal
Picture of Sal
Give Kaboul time, do me a
Give Kaboul time, do me a favour he has been one disaster after another. Bent is absolute pants but kevin prince hasnt been given a chance.

Tim
Picture of Tim
Boateng all day long, he
Boateng all day long, he can't keep the ball, make a pass, tackle, shoot or run. Bent's not the greatest but there's something there and Kaboul is a decent player who needs to play regularly and adapt to the league, I won't forget his goal when we played Villa at the Lane!

James
Picture of James
Kaboul - i feel like spurs
Kaboul - i feel like spurs will concede everytime he plays up back, not that boateng is much better - maybe needs to mature but for over 5mil? joke. i say let kaboul leave, juve or whoever can have him- bring in the spanish defenders anyday.

bob in L.A
Picture of bob in L.A
Under good coaching Kaboul
Under good coaching Kaboul has the physic to be a decent centre back, he hasen't had half the chances Dawson has this year and dosen't even have all his years of playing experience. He makes mistakes but scored goals too, more than that [*@!$] Zokora has in two years