Chelsea's Cech v Manchester United's Van der Sar v Liverpool's Reina - Who is the Premier League's No.1?

Tagged: Premiership
FanCast detective Fred Foley continues his investigation into the Premier League's best X1

As the race for the Premiership enters its final furlong and as we approach one of the most fascinating hurdles this coming weekend in what is seemingly now a three horse race, here at Football FanCast.com we are compiling a Premiership Select XI for the current campaign. We don't do things backwards here, so it's the number one shirt first up.

The ever debatable discussion of whether the Premier League boasts the finest players in the world continues to dominate many of English football's burning issues. Rarely within such discussion however do we hear the names of the footballers that can often be the focal point of many teams, the man whose performance has a direct effect on the confidence of his team-mates, the man who can be the first link between defence and attack - namely, the man between the sticks.

As you watch ‘goal of the month' you have to wonder whether the spectacular and sometimes astounding saves from our Premier League goalkeepers would merit more recognition than the ‘deflected off the elbow' finish that registers at number nine in the charts. But which goalkeeper deserves the most recognition? Which man could be the sole content of an ‘astonishing saves' DVD likely to rival DFS. Or, putting it simply, which goalkeeper is currently the Premiership's finest?

Although it is agreed that the following are not called into action as frequently as many of their Premier League counterparts, I feel you do not have to look past the Premiership's top four clubs to establish the top trio of safe hands.

Petr Cech

A phenomenal goalkeeper, the only word I feel that can do the man justice. Stands at 1.96m, and uses every inch to his outstanding ability. Prevented from appearing in eight of Chelsea's 29 league games this term, Cech's qualities have perhaps not been accentuated to the same degree as his performances in previous  - notably during Chelsea's consecutive title winning seasons.

Forgetting the metaphors regarding goalkeepers and wine; at a tender age of 25, Cech will no doubt continue to develop as one of the world's most gifted green-jerseyed player. Indeed, the Chelsea goalkeeper was only 2nd to a man five years his senior in the International Federation of Football History and Statistics (IFFHS) Best Goalkeeper of the Year Award for 2007 - Gianluigi Buffon. A man that is a further seven years the senior of the Czech international, is another man in contention for the title in discussion.


Edwin Van der Sar

Whilst the partnership of Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic has received deserved recognition when reflecting on the mere fifteen goals that have bulged the Manchester United net this Premier League season, the prowess of the Dutch international that provides the Champion's last line of defence should not be overlooked.

Eyebrows were raised when the ex-Ajax and Juventus goalkeeper made a summer from Fulham to Old Trafford in 2005, but the 37 year-old has proved his worth under the managership of Sir Alex and direction of retired coach Tony Coton. Standing at one millimetre above his Chelsea counterpart, the Dutch captain offers a unique presence behind United's back four, and combined with his agility and positional technique, his shot-stopping abilities are difficult to be rivalled with.

Pepe Reina

If we were to judge a goalkeeper solely on the ability to save a penalty, Jose Manuel Reina would (excuse the pun) reign supreme. The Liverpool goalkeeper has placed himself between the sticks on 30 occasions to date in this season's Premier League, and during which has replaced Ray Clemence as the quickest Liverpool player to notch 50 clean sheets, doing so in a rather impressive 92 outings.

Reina is another man that, in goalkeeping terms, is well before his peak, also currently just 25 years of age. Though perhaps not reaching the heights of his goalkeeping father, Miguel Reina Santos, the talents of the Liverpool number one will undoubtedly have been appreciated by Mr Benitez in this current campaign. Inspirational in this season's Champions League progress, and that of last, the agility and bounce that the Spaniard possesses define the goalkeeping style of the ex-Barcelona man.

Three teams, six hands; three of the Premiership's finest. The question of which goalkeeper should be wearing the first jersey that is placed on the dressing room pegs, remains.

 

Average: 3.1 (15 votes)
Kopstar
Picture of Kopstar
It will have to be Reina,
It will have to be Reina, the other two teams have solid backlines in front of them, his keeping is amazing especially at penalties.

Downing
Picture of Downing
I would have to plumb for
I would have to plumb for Cech, there is no keeper in the Premiership who comes close to him, he has no weakness, which is more than I can say for the other two.

Goon
Picture of Goon
Where is Almunia, how Reina
Where is Almunia, how Reina keeps him out of the national set up I will never know.

LFCKASH
Picture of LFCKASH
How Reina keeps Almunia out
How Reina keeps Almunia out of the national set-up??? Casillas(sp) is the national keeper for Spain you muppet! Go get a football education befor you go about commenting on such matters. YNWA

G-Man
Picture of G-Man
All fine goalkeepers but if
All fine goalkeepers but if you consider their ages and potential for improvement, you'd have to discount Van der Sar being the oldest. Both Cech and Reina are 25 and will only get better and, prior to this season, Cech would have got my vote. That said, he's looked uncharacteristically shaky this season. Reina has had a fine season and is the best of all 3x at sweeping up behind his defenders. Also great at initiating attacks and has had a couple of assists to his name already this season. A tough call perhaps but Reina shades it on form this season for me.

Johnboy
Picture of Johnboy
You will never know probably
You will never know probably because you know nothing about football Goon (wonder who you support!!) :-) Its between Cech & Reina IMO but I think Reina just shades it this season as Chech has mised a good part of it through injury and has looked a bit more error prone too. So its Reina for me & id have Almunia as around the 14th/15th best goolkeeper in the Prem :-) Id say David James should be in contention to with is form this season.

Stu
Picture of Stu
Cech 100% why are you even
Cech 100% why are you even having this poll?? no one comes close to him the only person who could give Cech a run for his money would be Cudicini.

Alex Hill
Picture of Alex Hill
Reina has won the Golden
Reina has won the Golden Gloves award the past two seasons and is in the lead to win it again this season...Given that there is still 5 - 10 years improvement to come from him, I would say that he is the best keeper in the Country as an all rounder. Cech is a great shot stopper and Van der Saar has been a legendary Goalkeeper but statistics speak for themselves and Pepe has kept more clean sheets.

chelsea blues
Picture of chelsea blues
i felt that when cech
i felt that when cech arrived he was the best goalkeeper to grace the premiership since schmeichal. but after watching some of the displays of reina of late i think, if i'm being honest, that he is just as good between the sticks. also i think that reina's distribution of the ball mean that he just edges it in my eyes. more than once i've seen him be the impetus hehind liverpool's counter attacks. as for van der sar he used to be great but i think its true that no one receives better protection than him and yet he still makes mistakes.

Alex Hill
Picture of Alex Hill
Agree with Johnboy - David
Agree with Johnboy - David James has been nothing short of world class this season for Pompey, shame he didnt do it earlier in his career when he was being hyped as one of the best

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Filtered words will be replaced with the filtered version of the word.
CAPTCHA
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

By posting on this site you are agreeing to keep your posts civil and tasteful at all times, and respect that everyone has their own opinion. Our writers and readers should be treated with respect. They want to be listened to and listen to others, they want to argue, voice their opinion and raise controversy. Both our writer's and reader's (you) have the right to their own opinion, and therefore will not be censored, unless it is deemed to be inappropriate, offensive or abusive behaviour.