Turn on a football related programme this weekend and you can expect to find a former player having his say about the sport we all love. With Robbie Savage working for the BBC and ESPN, Gary Neville for SKY and former Arsenal defenders, Lee Dixon and Martin Keown both on the BBC, the question has to be asked why football pundits must be formers players who were the most irritating of their time?

The simple answer is that we appear to live in a world where people who are most controversial succeed and these former players who have already established a reputation in the game use this to grind out a career in media after they have retired. By deliberately being controversial they guarantee a reaction from a viewer or reader, something that outside of football, comedians like Frankie Boyle and shock writers like Richard Littlejohn have realised to their advantage

With the added competition that showing football has, I think the media organisations like BBC and Sky are competing against each other to find the most controversial pundit who will ensure people tune into their coverage and not their rivals. The problem for footballers who are have a decent reputation in the game is that they struggle to gain controversy. A fine example is BBC pundit Alan Shearer who just seems to states the obvious every week on MOTD to everyone’s general annoyance and also Steve Claridge who does quite similar on the Football League Show. From the reaction when these two are on our screens it is obvious that football fans do not want to watch dullards discussing football and would rather someone who can keep them entertained, whether that is through intensive football knowledge or by making controversial statements that these supporters react to.

Gary Neville has been one of football most controversial and divisive figures for years during his illustrious playing career at Old Trafford. When Sky appointed him a pundit at the start of the new season they knew what they doing as Neville is never short of an opinion or two. I have actually been surprised by Neville’s intelligent and amiable punditry so far and he actually seems to think about the game. While soon to be dancer, Robbie Savage clearly has a bright future in the media profession as after hanging up his boots last season he won the Sony DAB Rising Star Award for his work on BBC Radio Five Live. Although I was not his biggest fan as a player he has carried through the controversial aspects of his game into his media career and he can certainly bring extra life to a mundane phone call during his 606 show. I actually think Lee Dixon is one of the best pundits around, his views on the MOTD2 sofa are normally well-thought out and balanced but he still maintains the ability to entertain, he is someone that pundits in better jobs like Shearer could learn from.

I think these newly retired players are freshening up the football media landscape after it had stagnated in recent year with many pundits who had been out of the game for many years falling out of touch with the game. Some of these younger pundits were involved in the game just last seasons so will have some idea what the manager is saying at half time or what players think of a certain referee, so their words carry more weight. This new breed of football pundit in the competitive world of football looks to continue and if this trend does carry as as it has I wouldn’t at all surprised to see in the future, pundits Joey Barton and El Hadj Diouf discussing the game on a Saturday night.

Fancy watching the Champions in style – sign up to 188Bet for an experience of a lifetime below

What do you think?

Sign in with Facebook and be
entered for a chance to
Win a pair of Puma evoPOWER football boots

Terms and Conditions

Why?

  • Sign up in 2 seconds
  • Use your FB profile image
  • No need to remember a password
  • See which of your friends would like this

Note: We don't post to your wall

Login

Comment without logging in

You will need to fill this out each time to comment so why not quickly login with Facebook!

*

What do you think?

Sign in with Facebook and be
entered for a chance to
Win a pair of Puma evoPOWER football boots

Terms and Conditions

Why login with Facebook?

  • Sign up in 2 seconds
  • Use your FB profile image
  • No need to remember a password
  • See which of your friends would like this

Note: We don't post to your wall


  • Don
    3 years ago

    As someone who has hired football pundits over the years, I can honestly say the biggest challenge is to find an ex-player who can actually string a sentence together and not freeze when the cameras start rolling. You’d likely be surprised how small a pool of people that leaves you with. In my opinion these pundits are not controversial enough, they still have relationships in the game that they don’t want to burn and the broadcasters are very wary of upsetting the PL by going too far and rein their ‘experts’ in a significant amount.

    Reply
  • Mick mac
    3 years ago

    UK football pundits are generally bland and uncontroversial often towing the line not to offend their former teamates and collegues in the game. Try the Irish TV station RTE for proper no holes barred and incisive punditry – Johnny Giles, Eamon Dunphy and Liam Brady – not controversial for the sake of it but straight up. Grame Soueness saw it firsthand duirng the last world cup as a guest pundit on the panel.

    Reply
    • Danny Salford Red
      3 years ago

      Eamon Dunphy is a legend and possibly the best/funniest pundit ive ever heard :-)

      Reply
    • Essexian76
      3 years ago

      Absolutely, I was in Cork when the Roy Keane incident happened in 2002, and was shocked at the response from the media and public with their no holds barred method of debate. It was actually like being in a pub with your mates debating, as opposed to the homogenised pap the British look for, perhaps TALKsport would consider a late night open house?

      Reply
  • Blimey
    3 years ago

    Well if it gets that one eyed Liverpool-biased twat Mark Lawro off the box then I’d welcome Joey Barton with open arms…!! and you can’t say you’ve heard that said very often??

    Reply
  • James
    3 years ago

    Lee Dixon a good pundit?! Maybe you dont remember before the england-germany world cup game he said “none of the germany XI would get in the england team”. He is a JOKE!

    Reply