FIVE Lessons Sunderland must learn going into next season

Date: 29th July 2012 at 10:39 am
Written by Alex Churcher | Comments (19)

Sunderland fans at the Stadium of LightSunderland’s preparations for the new season appear to have hit a wall as the club struggle to attract quality players to justify their lofty ambitions. A new chairman, manager and kit sponsor seemed to signal the beginning of a new era at the Stadium of Light but if their efforts so far this summer are an indication of things to come then mid-table mediocrity may be the most likely outcome. For a team that has only recently shaken off their yo-yo tag to establish themselves as a regular part of the Premier League, such reserved targets are not what the terraces want to hear but given the pitfalls suffered by the red and white part of North East in recent seasons, there are plenty of tough realities to be faced if the club is to move forward.

Curb expectation

Every year Sunderland fans embark on a new Premier League campaign with renewed vigour but every season is deemed a disappointment when the team doesn’t qualify for Europe. While fans have every right to demand the very best from their team, it’s clear to onlookers that the Blacks Cats do not yet have a good enough squad to compete with the top flight’s established European challengers. The appointment of Martin O’Neill as manager has supporters dreaming that he will repeat the success he enjoyed at Aston Villa and while that’s a reasonable target, the reality is the Mackems are still a long way of finishing in the top 6 and envious glares at rivals Newcastle United will make any future respectable league finishes seem like an underachievement.

Don’t focus so much on Newcastle

Many a season at the Stadium of Light has been ruined by a failure to overcome the archenemy and such is the importance placed on the Tyne-Wear derby that managers have often seen their careers in the North East judged on how they fared against the Geordies. Ex manager Steve Bruce even cited his local roots and derby struggles as the main catalyst of his demise but while the Corbridge born former defender struggled against Newcastle, he was given a fair crack of the whip by the majority of fans. Still the comparison between the sides was there for all to see last season and seeing their bitter rivals punch above their weight in the Premier League only heightened fans desperation for improvements on the pitch. Had any other team overachieved as Newcastle did last time out then Sunderland fans would have been less inclined to write off their manager and his new players but such is the hatred between fans that they turned on the management and booed the team. Rightly or wrongly, such impatience cannot be repeated next season for if Martin O’Neill is considered to be their messiah then he must be allowed time to mould his team together. New signings are expected but fans must not expect instant miracles, even if Newcastle fans are gloating because they’re playing in Europe.

Stop buying players from relegated teams

As O’Neill slowly stamps his authority on the team during his first full summer in charge, fans are debating the procrastinatory nature of his transfer dealings and wondering how much money there is to spend and who he’s thinking of spending it on. The usual scenario for Sunderland is they have roughly £20m-£30m to spend but often need 5 or more signings and end up bring in a selection of cheap squad players instead of investing in one or two genuine talents. This has led to them snapping up the star performers from previously relegated sides and while players like Sebastian Larsson, David Vaughan and Craig Gardner all represent excellent value for money, they’re not the quality of player needed to take the club to the next level. This summer has seen Steven Fletcher, Matt Jarvis, Steven N’Zonzi and Martin Olsson linked with the club but these players need to be avoided if they harbour any hopes of moving away from the mid-table pack.

Don’t buy Manchester United cast-offs

Another pitfall of previous Sunderland managers has been to wash Sir Alex Ferguson’s hands of his unwanted Old Trafford talent and with little reward. Currently Phil Bardsley, John O’Shea, Wes Brown, Kieran Richardson and Fraizer Campbell fill the quota more than capably but a brief skim down the history books shows a plethora of ex Red Devils brought in by former bosses Bruce and Roy Keane. The stark reality is that while these players may have seemed like they had decent pedigree and to a certain extent they satisfied the needs of an aspiring club on the rise from the Championship, the fact is they couldn’t make the Manchester United first team and are therefore not good enough if Sunderland want to push on to the next level.

Give the lads a chance!

Neutrals peering in on Sunderland’s situation often wonder why supporters demand so much of them given their underwhelming record in recent years. It’s been over a decade since Peter Reid’s side claimed back to back 7th place finishes and the Black Cats have little European pedigree to justify such lofty expectations. This may be true but Mackem fans know the club has a proud history and see their complaints more as constructive criticism then unwarranted condemnation. There are two sets of fans, the group with unrealistic expectations who demand success and the group with a realistic assessment of where the team is but are deemed to lack ambition. These fans needs to find some middle ground and let the team blossom without demanding too much from a side that are clearly worse off on paper than the League’s top teams and will need all the support they can get if their are to progress.

Supporting a so called lesser side is often a hiding to nothing as fans’ aspirations to improve are hampered by the reality of their mid-table predicament. If the Sunderland faithful have learned anything going into next season it should be not to expect success but rather enjoy it, if and when it comes along.

Should Sunderland fans have more realistic expectations or should they have loftier ambitions ahead of next season?

Let me know your views and opinions by following me on Twitter – Tweet me @Alex_Churcher

19 Comments

- Leave a comment
  • Shadow
    July 29th, 2012

    havent got any problem with sunderland exept that nutter catermole , an accident waitings to happen, and a minority of their fans, as you rightly stated they give the toon far too much attention while teams like man city and man united fob them off as shit and easy to beat, for me a much bigger problem with football is the fans getting at each others throats its not a chance to wage war.

  • Bilbo Baggins
    July 29th, 2012

    Complete and utter clichéd drivel.

  • Always Right
    July 29th, 2012

    what a load of rubbish

  • FreddiesFlatCap
    July 29th, 2012

    a) Sunderland fans do not expect Europe every season. Yes, we start every new campaign with a sense of optimism, as do most fans of most clubs. All we want is progress matching the investment that has been made in the club over recent years. That is why the VAST MAJORITY of SAFC fans would be over the moon if the club became established in the top ten and possibly even broke into the top eight.

    b)Why are the national media, blogs, forums etc obsessed with the SAFC – NUFC rivalry. Most SAFC fans have mates who are NUFC fans. It’s no different from any other rivalry and SAFC fans are far more concerned with our own club than we are with ‘them up the road’..P.S. STEVE BRUCE – YOU WERE NOT SACKED BECAUSE OF YOUR ‘GEORDIE ROOTS’!!!!

    c) Martin O’Neill has consistently said that he knows which players he wants to bring in. These deals don’t happen overnight. Ellis Short has confirmed that he will be backing O’Neill in bringing quality not quantity to the squad. Money has been squandered on squad players by each of the last two permanent managers (Keane & Bruce) resulting in a complete overhaul of the squad each summer. I think O’Neill & Short know what they’re doing and will avoid that scenario now and over the coming seasons.

    d) As stated above Keane & Bruce brought in loads of squad players, several of which were signed either on loan or on permanent deals from Man Utd. Do you not think this had something to do with Bruce & Keane both being former captains of Utd? I doubt O’Neill will go down the same route as those two.

    e) As I stated at the beginning SAFC fans have reasonable expectations. I don’t recall any National awareness of SAFC fans’ expectations prior to Steve Bruce’s propaganda campaign to whitewash the real reasons for his sacking. We, like all fans, want to see the team give 100% every game, do their best to win every game and justify the cost of going to the match. If your comment about expectation stems from what you’ve heard Steve Bruce spouting over the past nine months I can tell you the fans turned against him because performances were abysmal for TEN MONTHS!! It is not an over-expectation to want to see more than 4 home wins in 18 home league games across a ten month period!!!

    • Alex Churcher
      July 29th, 2012

      Regarding your points!: a) naturally fans would be ‘over the moon’ but there are also certain criticisms aimed at the club by fans when they don’t finish in the top 10, despite them having little precedent to do so.
      b) The rivalry is still extremely passionate regardless of friendly examples. Also the article does mention fans gave Bruce a chance despite his roots.
      c & d)Agreed, but it remains to seen how things progress.
      e) My comment about expectations comes from being a Sunderland fan myself and witnessing the anger when things dont go to plan. IMO Bruce was deservedly sacked but the club is still a way behind the top teams and Newcastle should not be used as a blue print for they punched above their weight while other teams underachieved.
      At the end of the day, the article is about ‘lessons to be learned’ and is therefore unlikely to be filled with praise, rather open for debate the mistakes the club have made, even if the truth is sometimes hard to read! :)

      • NUFC fan
        July 29th, 2012

        oh dear, oh dear, did you actually watch us play at all last season, or is this just another cliche band wagon you’ve jumped on… We punched above our weight?? Ok 4-5 games is a lucky streak, we managed 38 league games without dropping below 7th place, but of course we weren’t there by merit….

        • Alex Churcher
          July 29th, 2012

          Not get me wrong, you absolutely were there by merit, but that’s not the point. Your total league points would not normally be so successful but for the usual suspects ie. Liverpool, Spurs, Arsenal and Chelsea all having major blips during an unpredictable season. Again you beat the teams put in front of you so absolutely deserve the rewards but given you and everybody else didn’t expect such success, you clearly did ‘punch above your weight’ however deserved it was.

  • Phil Johnson
    July 29th, 2012

    It would appear that your article is a “space filler” without any substance.

    To make it even worse, you appear to contradict yourself in your, various, references to the expectations of SAFC supporters.

    I trust that you were not paid for this drivel!

    • Alex Churcher
      July 29th, 2012

      I’m not sure what you mean but please feel free to tell me where I contradicted myself and will do my best to explain my reasoning.

      • jimy bong
        August 12th, 2012

        you are a bellend fella

  • Dave Parker
    July 29th, 2012

    Clearly written by a Newcastle fan. Talking about curbing expectations, try telling Newcastle fans that they arent going to win wor leaaaague as they say.

    • NUFC fan
      July 29th, 2012

      So it’s fair to say about Newcastle who have been through a humbling time over the last few seasons but not about SAFC??

      If you give it then you deserve to get it back.

      I wrote the post below in respect of the majority of our fans but it’s 12 year olds like you that give the southern press their ammo!

    • Alex Churcher
      July 29th, 2012

      Actually I’m a Sunderland fan, just willing to be truthful about my concerns! An article on lessons to be learned is unlikely to praise the club after all.

  • NUFC fan
    July 29th, 2012

    Being a life long Newcastle supporter I’m used to this southern written drivel about the northern most teams in the league.

    I think it’s a common misconception that NUFC and SAFC supporters EXPECT European football every season and to be challenging in the upper echelons of the Premier League. I think you’ll find we have some of the most passionate supporters of any football teams and:
    a) A desire to see our teams perform as well as their wage packages demands them to and as much as the investment in the team requires.
    b) For our teams to entertain us.

    Speaking as a NUFC supporter, I never expected us to do as well as we did last year and I don’t demand or expect us to challenge the top 4 this year. I want to see attractive football, a top half of the table finish and a better run in the cups than last year. Just the same as any fan, I want to see improvement!

    Lazy journalism with substandard cliches I suppose it’s just a slow, Sunday page filler.

    • Alex Churcher
      July 29th, 2012

      Blogs are opinions, not news reports. As a NUFC fan you are not commented upon in this article and at no point is it said that NUFC fans demand European football. It’s about SAFC. The article is about lessons to be learned and therefore is unlikely to sing the praises of a club but rather open their problems up for debate.

      • NUFC fan
        July 29th, 2012

        No but we are held in the same regard, I was just defending another club which has the same cliched “expectation” label on them as ourselves, I never said you had said we demand european football, that was used as an example of the same trash written about us as you have written about SAFC. Don’t get me wrong, come match day I hope we wipe the floor with these lot but I can empathise with them when someone confuses hope and passion with expectation. My point was that all is expected is attractive football, commitment, passion and most importantly progression.

        • Alex Churcher
          July 29th, 2012

          I agree and I think that’s a fair assessment of what most fans expect but again the good aspects of their support are not relevant to this article purely because of its theme, ie. things they need to learn.

  • Graham 'Fatty' Laidler
    July 29th, 2012

    Can’t disagree with most of that article. Especially not trying to catch Newcastle. We should look after ourselves and in MON we trust

  • Raghav
    September 26th, 2012

    I knew they would get the win, I fancy them to beat Chelsea at Old Trafford too, Chelsea have been unusually weak this sesoan, United are just starting to peak, really late on, but this sesoan has been a weird one!.

Your Opinion:

*


Regular commenter? Why not login or register: