The ONE thing the Premier League is truly lacking?

Date: 6th November 2011 at 11:20 am
Written by jimmyareabi | Comments (20)

During the last decade in football, the slow demise of Serie A has left just two leagues competing for the tag of the ‘Greatest in the World’; the English Premier League and Spain’s La Liga.

Both have always figured amongst the ‘elite’ leagues in Europe and contain some of the biggest, well known, sporting giants of the world game. Between them, they have won the Continent’s biggest prize – the European Cup/Champions League, 24-times in the 56-year history of the competition (with the Spanish winning 13 and the English 11). Both leagues have also been home to some of the greatest players the world has ever seen, but presently, La Liga stands alone as the country of choice for the truly world class player. You see for all its glamour, excitement and competitiveness, the English Premier League lacks a legitimate world class player – and La Liga has them in abundance.

Don’t get me wrong, the Premier League currently contains some of the biggest names in the game, known globally with fans stretching from North America all the way to Japan. Names like Rooney, Gerrard, Tevez and Torres are worshipped, and are (form/injury permitting) indeed, fantastic players. But since 2009 when Cristiano Ronaldo chose to leave English shores, swapping Manchester for Madrid, the truly world class players all now ply their trade in La Liga. But why is this?

Is it the contrast in styles? The English league has always been the most physically demanding league in Europe, with its end-to-end, non-stop tempo and the never-say-die attitude of both players and fans alike, lead to a more exciting spectacle for a full 90-minutes. The speed and toughness was coupled with fair play which became another trade-mark of the league, leading to a vast respect around the world. When the Premier League era was established along with all the marketing glitz, hype and glamour, the money came pouring in, which in turn, led to a foreign influx at both playing and coaching level. Skill levels rose, as did professionalism in all areas, from the training to the dieticians. The game became more technical – but in this area the Premier League was still playing catch-up to much of the Continent and in particular, La Liga.

Not as tactically ‘shackled’ as Serie A, La Liga always prized itself on high levels of skill, technique and attacking verve. Fans would go to the stadiums to be entertained. For many, to win simply wasn’t enough – you had to win with style. A natural attraction occurred. Traditionally, the world’s greatest players have mostly been attack minded; ranging from offensive midfielders (and I don’t mean Joey Barton here) to forwards. From its inception in 1991, only one defender won FIFA’s World Player of the Year award. It’s been a similar situation in the Ballon d’Or awards, were a goalkeeper was named once and defenders were named three times in a history which stretches back to 1956. Since 2008, two men have been recognised as the greatest players in the world; Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi – with Messi now standing alone as the undisputed best. Where do they both reside?


The grand names of Barcelona and Real Madrid also help Spain’s cause in attracting the truly world class players (or in Barcelona’s cause, developing them) to La Liga. But this is not a new thing; they always have done. Names like Cruyff, Di Stefano, Maradona, Ronaldo, Zidane and Ronaldinho have all wore their colours. Indeed, a massive 20-winner’s of the Ballon ‘dOr either played for, or went onto play for the two La Liga giants. Money and the glamour of representing these two famous clubs are also factors why they are many a world class player’s choice of location – and location is probably another major factor. Yes, the ‘great’ British weather also puts the Premier League at a big disadvantage when it comes to signing world stars. Sad as it may sound, how many times have you heard of foreign players preferring warmer climes and complaining about our weather?

As stated earlier, the Premier League is home to some amazingly talented players and in the past, the league (with the help from Sky) touted some of these players as the world’s ‘best’. But the likes of Gerrard, Drogba, Torres and Lampard have all passed their peak. Until Wayne Rooney consistently performs against bigger clubs during big games, and on the international stage, he too will remain below the ‘true great’ level. There is potential that a current crop could make the leap – the likes of David Silva, Luis Saurez, Mata and Aguero. But time will tell if they a) make that final step-up a notch, then b) not leave the league for Spain (or elsewhere) as Ronaldo and Fabregas did, and Tevez wants to do.

With the current cream of world football in Messi, Ronaldo, Xavi, Iniesta, Kaka, David Villa and Alonso all lighting-up La Liga, the Premier League lacks any true world greats – but then, when was it any different?

If you want to read more from myself including news, thoughts and views you can follow me on Twitter @fantasista1077 thanks!


FREE football ad that pays you to view ads

20 Comments

- Leave a comment
  • RedScot
    October 10th, 2011

    I believe being a youngish Scottish lad that the tag “the greatest in the world” is a matter of exposure on the various mediums to view world football.The greatest goes hand in hand with the width of coverage the two said leagues are afforded throughout the world, not hand in hand with quality of competition within the league!.As everybody is aware in Scotland only realistically Rangers and Celtic(in no particular order lol) stand a fighting chance of topping the SPL.Sadly as we all are also aware due to exposure on the television in La liga and the Barclays Premiership only two teams have competed effectively consistently to top the premiership(sorry Arsenal) since its inception and the SKY injection of finance to motivate the clubs investment.Since the SKY investment and Liverpools turmoil at the immature stage of the new concept and rules, they have not competed as they did prior to and not invested to the same level as previously like other major players in the league, in stadia etc.Arsenal eventually caught on as are Chelsea now sensing they are being left behind in the wake of Manchester United and the “work in progress,spent NORTH of 3/4 Billion pounds to date” City.
    The two leagues I think that are overlooked where competition and a regular changing of the “top dog” in the league that are ommited are the Bundesliga and the fabulous French league that both produce as is refered to world class players and world cup winning teams, through grass roots football and a forward thinking plan.
    Mark my words (lol) Germany will win the European Championship in Eastern Europe next summer.Sacre Bleu! lol

    • jimmyareabi
      October 11th, 2011

      Slightly off topic with the point of this article but a good reply non the less thanks:) . Exposure no doubt helps play a part – maybe a reason why it often takes a move to a ‘big’ club for an already great player to be recognised as such by the powers that be when handing out the World Player awards. Sound basis for another article though and I agree with some of the issues you raise.

  • andrew
    October 10th, 2011

    Though matter what, epl remains the best.

    • RedScot
      October 10th, 2011

      The point of the article, in my opinion, was as I IGNORED the star players in the world, outwith the E.P.l and La liga.Discuss the top players in the Bundesliga or France 1.Merci. Purely for balance.

    • jimmyareabi
      October 11th, 2011

      Not the point of the article, as RedScot has pointed out.

  • Paul
    October 10th, 2011

    Why is all the la liga players mentioned playing for either Barca or Real?? Are there no other world class players in any of the other teams? The reason la liga looks so good to us Brits is because of Skys coverage of the Barca and Madrid games. When the rest of the spanish league becomes as entertaining as the bottom 15 clubs in the premier league, this article may have some foundation. Until then, it’s just drivel I’m afraid.

    • jimmyareabi
      October 11th, 2011

      Maybe because the worlds current ‘greatest’ play for those clubs? Yes, there are other great players in other teams, but they have some way to go before dislodging Messi & Ronaldo from the top. If this was 2007/8 we would be also talking about Kaka (Milan), Torres & Gerrard (Liverpool),and the Ronaldo of Man Utd. The article is also not about which league is better, just stating fact that since Ronaldo left & other players have declined, the prem has no player CURRENTLY who can lay claim to the worlds greatest player title.

  • Trueblue
    October 11th, 2011

    The tax regime and the climate in Spain, may not sound important when talking purely in football terms. However when you can chose any country to ply your trade, why not pick a nice sunny place where the taxman dosen’t squeeze your balls till your eyes bleed!

    • essexian76
      October 11th, 2011

      So, it’s all off to Greece then?

    • jimmyareabi
      October 11th, 2011

      Exactly. As mentioned, unfortunately the climate does play a big part in a players choice. Great point about the tax laws too.

  • james
    October 11th, 2011

    yes spain has world class stars. but most reside in barcelona. madrid has maybe 2? ronaldo, and maybe kaka. higuian is not as good as aguero. pepe is not as good as vidic or terry, etc. also the premiership has had some of the truly best. Bergkamp. Henry. Giggs. Scholes. Vieria. keane. all played their best in the premiership. All would walk into any team in their pomp

    • jimmyareabi
      October 11th, 2011

      I agree to an extent. Whilst those past Premier League players were indeed great and would get into most teams, how many were actually considered as ‘the best’ of there time? None won either World Player of the Ballon D’or – there was always somebody better around (eg. Baggio, Zidane, Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Figo). Equally with Aguero, Higuain, Pepe, Vidic & Terry.

  • Al
    October 11th, 2011

    So where did David silva, aguero and juan mata come from? Oh yeh spain!! You don’t mean jumping ship to Spain, only to Madrid or barca. stupid article. Basically jus sayin every top player has to play for barca or real to become elite. I repeat stupid article. Watch city play this season and watch how Chelsea play under AVB. No I don’t support either of these teams.

    • jimmyareabi
      October 11th, 2011

      Watching City/Chelsea THIS season has no bearing on the article. I mentioned the above players as possibilities to be acknowledged as the worlds ‘best’ in the FUTURE, regardless of who they are playing for. At the moment, they are not ‘the best’. If you read the article properly and look at the history and facts, you will find that lots who have been crowned as the worlds ‘best’ HAVE played for either Barcelona or Real Madrid. That’s not what I am saying, that is fact, like it or not. Currently the two best players in the world play for those clubs. When Ronaldo played for United and won it he was challenged by both Torres and Messi for the title – no Real Madrid in the picture then & two from the Premier Lge. That’s the point of the article; that was then this is now – hence what the Prem is truly lacking

  • Rash
    October 11th, 2011

    dis article is absurd … Think of dis if u were given a option to watch a game not featuring barca or real wud u watch it? Or wud u rather watch spurs play newcastle / stoke ? My answer is simple i will watch d latter D premier league is much exciting and on any given day any team can beat any other n frankly i dont watch a game for star players bt watch it for fun n i hav it in excesss at premier league n the notion dat players wanna play in spain is only becoz of d fact dat spain has a lax tax law and d players want to hav more money wid themselves den wid a tax keeper

    • jimmyareabi
      October 11th, 2011

      This article is not about which league is better, merely pointing out that since Ronaldo left the Premiership, along with the decline of former stars, the Prem is currently lacking a true world great. Your comment would be valid for another argument in another thread, thanks.

  • Roy Singh
    October 11th, 2011

    There are 2 different styles of play – EPL more pace. Other European countries play at a slower pace. Comparatively I enjoy EPL games.However,I find it hard to understand why some EPL teams struggle against these teams during CL fixtures.

  • true gooner
    November 6th, 2011

    That was an interesting article, however, there are other world class plying their trade in other leagues all over the world i.e. Hulk @ Porto; Neymar & Ganso @ Santos; Lucas Paizon @ Sao Paulo; Alexander Pato @ AC Milan; Thiago Silva @ AC Milan; Robin Van Persie @ Arsenal is class; Jack Wilshire @ Arsenal; David Luiz @ Chelsea
    but to mention but a few!

    U have a point with the EPL but I truly believe that balance will shift in the next 2-3 seasons!

    Good article btw

  • Javier
    November 7th, 2011

    I´m Spanish, and I don´t think so. You have every weekend more fun watching Premier League than La Liga! The Premier League fans in Spain are increasing month by month.
    La Liga has more glamour than Premier, ok, but this is the kind of football we want? No, we want a football style than Premier League.
    See the statistics: In La Liga,only 55% of the match’s time is played. Very Bored.
    I don´t know if i writting well in English, but I Know i´m understandable.

    • Showbiz
      December 22nd, 2011

      I’m from Spain to and…. that’s not true, pleople is not getting a EPL fan.

      I think the problem is we have right now two teams above no only spain but europe this makes the big gap in La Liga right now. If you walk on history you will see this difference was never that big.

Your Opinion:

*


Regular commenter? Why not login or register: