Tottenham left with an ageing, unbalanced squad

Date: 1st July 2012 at 11:42 am
Written by Hamish Mackay | Comments (24)

In comparison to previous clubs, Harry Redknapp left Spurs in a reasonable  state. Southampton’s travail in the years subsequent to Redknapp’s departure was an indication of the danger of the manager’s methods. Portsmouth were to discover that for themselves. Though the financial strife at his previous clubs could not be entirely blamed on Redknapp’s transfer policy, it undoubtedly put strains on the finances of the clubs. His signing’s at Portsmouth were numerous and included players such as Jermain Defoe, Peter Crouch, Lassana Diarra, Glen Johnson and John Utaka – taking the wage bill at Portsmouth to an, unsustainable, record high.

At Tottenham, under the careful stewardship of Daniel Levy, the prospect of a repeat performance from Redknapp was unlikely – especially considering the funds available to the club. However, in the wake of Redknapp’s dismissal, the short termism displayed by Harry has left the squad in a condition far from it’s peak.

The squad appears unbalanced both in terms of players’ age, position and their futures. Suggestions have been made that Levy’s inability to trust the fact that Redknapp had a long tem plan for the club was a cause for his dismissal; one look at the squad suggests this may be the case.

The first problem Spurs need to address is that Redknapp has left them with only one striker. Peter Crouch was unceremoniously sold last season, before Pavlyuchenko departed for Lokomotiv Moscow in an £8m deal, Louis Saha’s short-term deal expired and Emmanuel Adebayor returned to Manchester City.

Jermain Defoe, for all the improvement in his hold up play this year, is not equipped to play as a lone striker and the only remaining option Spurs have is Giovanni Dos Santos – a player who had minimal playing time under Redknapp and is not used to playing as a main striker.

Now, defenders of Redknapp would argue that he was simply getting rid of ineffectual strikers but the fact remains that Tottenham need to sign at least two strikers this summer and, depending on how much they spend, that could rule out the possibility of adding to their squad in other areas.

The central defence is also a problem. With King finally being released and Gallas’ injury problems, which began at Chelsea and have got considerably worse over time, ruling him out for around half a season every season then Tottenham only really have Kaboul and Dawson, who has had a torrid time with injury himself.

Corluka too has been sold and although Kyle Naughton is returning from his loan at Norwich he cannot play at centre half as comfortably as Corluka could.

Then you have the situation with the goalkeepers. Brad Friedel may have begun his Tottenham career well but his late season form was indicative of his age. The American is now 41 and his form will only get worse from here on. Carlo Cudicini and Heurelho Gomes may be reasonable keepers but their poor performances were the reason Friedel was signed in the first place.

Finally, the midfield. Arguably one of the strongest in the league and with Gareth Bale having recently signed a contract extension many at the club will be feeling relieved. Nevertheless, the star man in the midfield – Luka Modric – is reportedly eyeing the exit door and although they may receive a high fee for him a lot of that money will be needed to help purchase cover up front and in central defence.

Tottenham is far from being in a crisis, but there is work to be done. As much as Redknapp made some brilliant signings whilst at Spurs and delivered success to the club the next manager will be feeling the strain when it comes to rebuilding. And, if that is the case, and that new manager is Andre Villas-Boas, then Spurs fans should be worried considering the Portuguese manager’s last attempts at rebuilding a squad in English football.

Follow me on Twitter @H_Mackay

24 Comments

- Leave a comment
Page:
1 2 3
  • Jay
    July 1st, 2012

    Redknapp is a crap manager yes, which is why he was sacked and why he didnt get the England job but Levy runs Tottenham.

    Saha, Nelson, King, Gallas and Friedel are our only notable over 30 year olds, 4 of the 5 wont be here next season.

    Caulker, Naughton will replace them and then the signing of Vertonghen 25 and Sigurdsson 22 will put the squad to the same number as before.

    So how exactly is it unbalanced

  • BazSpur
    July 1st, 2012

    What rubbish. We have a fairly young squad compared to some.

  • Northern Spur
    July 1st, 2012

    Interesting perspective but it appears that you have like Harry forgotten the younger promising players such as Smith, Kane and Caulker and others who could provide the balance.

  • Hawkins
    July 1st, 2012

    Some good points but completely ignores the return of Caulker from loan, Vertoghen will arrive once his hassle with Ajax is sorted and we have Huddlestone back. Add to that some good young talent such as Kane coming through, and things aren’t as unbalanced as the article suggests.

  • TD
    July 1st, 2012

    The general gist of your piece is correct but you’ve not done much research !.Spurs back line will include Walker,Caulker (remember him!), Kaboul, Dawson, Vertonghen, BAE and possibly Naughton.

    The Midfield has Bale, Huddlestone, Sandro ,Livermore and Lennon seasoned PL campaigners now yet all under 25 or under while Modric will go for a heap of money which will be used to buy more younger players like Gylfi Sigurdsson (22).A host of youngsters also featured in our Europa League run and have done well on loan so could possibly force their way into the first team squad.

    Strikers and Goalies need sorting out i’ll grant you that !.

  • davspurs
    July 1st, 2012

    Firstly Harry never signed any players Levey did the hiring and firing. Secondly we have Caulker Huddlestone 6ft3 plenty of youngsters waiting Smith Parret Kane Townsend Coulibaly Carrol and others We have Vertonghen in the wings Surgoson and i believe Ady will be bought

  • elwehbi
    July 1st, 2012

    King released? You must be ITK.

  • oldgaz
    July 1st, 2012

    Are you a visitor to this planet or just have shit for brains?Suggest you expend your energies on commenting on the imminent demise of football in Scotland

  • Ed
    July 1st, 2012

    It’s unbalanced because we have one striker, 3000 central midfielders, 2 wingers, 3 fullbacks. We essentially need to make a feck load of signings this window to compensate for all the stop gaps and cheap “he’ll do for the squad” type signings Redknapp made. Never healthy to do it all in one window. We have one striker in Jermain Defoe, so when we approach a club for a striker we’ll have to pay way over the odds for them.

  • BOB
    July 1st, 2012

    We got faith in you Andre and you Mr Levy. You show us fans respect and try make the right decision we’ll be patient.Fuck the fans whos always hating they dont understand football and just read them tabloids

Page:
1 2 3

Please log in to comment: