Three episodes of fly-on-the-wall documentary ‘Being: Liverpool’ have already hit our screens, and the nagging question remains as to what on earth to make of it all.

Everyone I’ve spoken to seems to have a different opinion on what they have seen so far. Some have described it as fascinating, others cringeworthy.

Former Liverpool defender Mark Lawrenson agrees with the latter. The Match of the Day pundit wrote in his weekly column that the show would have left Liverpool legends Bill Shankly, Bob Paisley and Joe Fagan ‘turning in their graves’.

“What on earth is Brendan Rodgers doing in this programme Being: Liverpool?’, writes Lawrenson, who also slammed the club’s American owners.

“I’m sorry, I just think this show comes across as American schmalz. It’s totally ill-advised and some of the stuff that I have seen so far in the first three episodes is cringeworthy.

“I think everybody shares that point of view. The problem is, once you get American owners intent on doing it and intent on getting everyone involved it’s extremely difficult.”

Strong words perhaps, but does Lawrenson have a point?

The difficulty that I and others I have spoken to have with the show, is the uncertainty surrounding how much of it is staged, with Brendan Rodgers the prime suspect for over-doing things.

Rodgers is something of an ego-maniac, judging by the gigantic self portrait hanging in his hallway.

Incase you were wondering, it’s not a prop. This is the same man who had a cardboard cutout of himself in his office at Swansea, as we discovered last season on a behind the scenes look at the clubs training ground as a feature on Gillette Soccer Saturday. 

He does have the look of a man enjoying his time in front of the camera, and has a superb selection of cliche’s ready to drop at will.

Within five minutes of the first episode, the Liverpool manager declared: “I wasn’t so much born with a silver spoon in my mouth, but a silver shovel,” in an attempt to explain he understands the value of working for everything you get.

“You educate people, you train dogs,” he says with a smug look on his face as he speaks of his ‘new age’ methods and attitudes to coaching.

“I always believe the player plus the environment equals the behaviour”, is Rodgers next slogan, taken straight out of Andre Villas-Boas’s coaching manual.

Does he actually speak like this to his players when the camera’s are not around? Fair play to him if that is the case, each to their own. But it’s extremely hard to fathom.

A problem for Liverpool fans is the fact that filming started the day Rodgers sat in the Anfield hot seat. As if the guy doesn’t have enough to contend with, he’s just taken charge of the most successful club in Britain and is tasked with reviving it’s fortunes. Now he has an American camera crew following his every move.

It is not the sort of thing you can imagine former managers Rafael Benitez or Kenny Dalglish being happy doing.Benitez was a maticulous no-nonsense coach who would not let anything stand in the way of his work.

Dalglish struggled enough being interviewed by Geoff Shreeves.

But Rodgers seems to be enjoying himself a little too much and seems to be using it as an opportunity to show himself as the next Pep Guardiola or perhaps in his opinion, the next Jesus Christ.

When John W. Henry bought Liverpool, he spoke of wanting to return to doing things ‘The Liverpool Way’. It is my understanding the Liverpool way was doing things behind closed doors, with dignity and grace.

It is hard to see where a documentary that goes as far as showing the clubs managing director Ian Ayre, making his way home after concluding a £15million transfer deal on a motorbike that screams midlife crisis, is in keeping with such tradition?

The documentary does make fascinating viewing, and gives an insight into the world of professional football not seen before. There are those who feel some things should be kept sacred, and the documentary broadcasts things that should not be seen, such as pre match team talks and the completion of transfer deals.

However times are changing, with the introduction of social media and rich owners pumping billions of pounds into clubs you feel more clubs may follow suit in the future. We live in a time where what the clubs owners says goes.

But first and foremost, Liverpool fans want to see their team doing well on the pitch – something that hasn’t been the case for the past three seasons now – and this season hasn’t started well in terms of results.

Rodgers has to concentrate on getting results first and foremost before dropping endless cliche’s to an American camera crew.

Everything in football is dictated by results. If Liverpool were top of the table, there would no doubt be much more positive feeling about the documentary, rather than those saying it is nothing more than an attempt from the American owners to promote Liverpool in a glossy magazine style to a worldwide audience.

It’s a good money making move from John W.Henry and his team. But you feel Liverpool fans would be more positive about the idea if just an extra £1million made from the ‘Being’ franchise was invested in Clint Dempesy on deadline day, and the club had that extra striker to help them compete on the pitch. That is what will always be the most important thing for Liverpool fans.

What have you made of ‘Being: Liverpool’ so far? Fascinating or cringeworthy? Follow me on Twitter @LukeGreenwood89 and let me know your thoughts. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

What do you think?

Sign in with Facebook and be
entered for a chance to
Win a pair of Puma evoPOWER football boots

Terms and Conditions

Why?

  • Sign up in 2 seconds
  • Use your FB profile image
  • No need to remember a password
  • See which of your friends would like this

Note: We don't post to your wall

Login

Comment without logging in

You will need to fill this out each time to comment so why not quickly login with Facebook!

*

What do you think?

Sign in with Facebook and be
entered for a chance to
Win a pair of Puma evoPOWER football boots

Terms and Conditions

Why login with Facebook?

  • Sign up in 2 seconds
  • Use your FB profile image
  • No need to remember a password
  • See which of your friends would like this

Note: We don't post to your wall


  • Felderkirk
    2 years ago

    Yes, I find it hard to disagree with this. Most of us LFC supporters seem to totally agree with Brendan’s tactics and his approach. It’s just that he speaks far too much and gives too much away. I saw an interview this morning in which he was defending Joe Allen from criticism by Alan Shearer, and he basically spelled out exactly what his tactics would be in every game we play until Lucas returns from injury. It’s naive.

    Reply
  • Luke Greenwood
    2 years ago

    I saw the same interview and totally agree. It’s not really in keeping with the ‘Liverpool way’ as such. I have seen a clip from the new episode out on Friday which has left me very confused.

    http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/being-liverpool-brendan-rodgers-envelope-1369893

    Reply
  • Alex-Young
    2 years ago

    I’ve seen the fourth episode and it doesn’t get any better. The envelope bit is very odd – although I think it’s fairly obvious there’s nothing in them. It’s probably just Rodgers playing up to the cameras.

    Reply
  • Justin
    2 years ago

    Keeping in mind that it is a “reality” TV show, I struggle to see this point of view. More specifically the analysis of Brendan Rodgers in it. In all of the interviews I have listened to and seen of Rodgers he is as enigmatic and well spoken. I struggle to expect anything else from him in this series as that is who he is. Jose Mourihno exhibits a swagger and a poise about the work that he does, and it is loved by the British media. A young manager who has a philosophy and a bright future expresses some self belief and he is described as an “ego-maniac”. Finally the comment on the portrait, a gift from charity, I thought that was well publicized already? poor article.

    Reply
    • Alex-Young
      2 years ago

      So you don’t feel that Rodgers is being self-indulgent at all? I’ve enjoyed the series so far – but at times ol’ Brendan does come across rather…well, self-righteous.

      Reply
      • Luke Greenwood
        2 years ago

        Whether it’s a gift from a charity or not, it’s still comical.

        I’m not slating Rodgers as a manager, I back him at Liverpool and what he is trying to do. The results have been poor but there has been an improvement in their play and I think given time he will be a success.

        But with your reference to Jose Mourinho, you expect him to exhibit swagger and poise like that because of what he has achieved.

        Rodgers is not close to that level yet, he’s had a couple of good seasons with Swansea City.

        I just find the documentary a bit cringeworthy, and struggle to think he isn’t playing up to the camera’s in some way shape or form.

        But everyone has their own opinion on it, so thanks for expressing yours.

        Reply
  • livlova
    2 years ago

    I think its a load of rubbish

    Reply
  • kevin
    2 years ago

    As far as the being Liverpool.. not seen much of it, a lot of people I know have, all seem quite interested and keep tuning in each week or recording it, in the days of reality tv its a first! if it was Barcelona we would be glued to the set . manutd new venture?? look at the sign up on utds site running an effort to get as many man utd fans to meet at a New York spot what is it a train station !. All a bit hokey but its all branding to the US.we have decent owners not fools..anymore look back 2 years this is what we prayed for …give it time .As far as Rogers I think give him 3 years no quick fix stick with him and the club through thick n thin.. Yes its hard not switching the TV on for a week and watching repeats or opinions of a crap game.He is articulate ,confident and great for us. Look what the media done to Raffa at times? that’s why Dalgliesh was pay back towards them!

    Reply
  • Alan
    2 years ago

    People need to take it with a pinch of salt and “Lawro” is a just sad bitter man, his opinion is worthless regarding anything football and LFC related.

    Reply
  • Simon Antony
    2 years ago

    Yeah becuase the liverpool way has been working so over the past 23 years.

    Reply
    • Luke Greenwood
      2 years ago

      No, it hasn’t. Hence why Henry spoke of wanting to get back to it. As entertaining and interesting as the documentary may be, I don’t see how it’s helping that cause.

      Reply