This is a contentious issue. Different people see things in players that others don’t while fans are understandably always quick to stand up for their own players.
To be classed as overrated is simply for a player to be thought of as better than they actually are. This means that very good players that are labelled as legends or world beaters are overrated, as are bog-standard players who continue to play for the Premier League’s top teams each and every week.
I can guarantee that you won’t agree with a handful of these selections, but then football would be pretty boring if we all agreed!